August 2016 talk, Serial No. 00182, Side A

00:00
00:00
Audio loading...

Welcome! You can log in or create an account to save favorites, edit keywords, transcripts, and more.

Serial: 
MS-00182A

AI Suggested Keywords:

AI Summary: 

The talk delves into the profound nature of sacrifice as a fundamental human act, exploring its ties to rituals, myths, and its role in transforming personal and community life. The speaker engages deeply with various religious and cultural practices of sacrifice, narrating experiences and theoretical insights that highlight the ceremonial importance and transformational potential of sacrifice.

**References and further readings:**
- **The Song of the Bird** by Father Anthony DeMello, which informs the discussion on personal revelation and spiritual insight.
- Reflections on the teachings of **St. Benedict** and his rules about understanding the essence of words and roles within religious life.
- Insights from **Rudolf Bultmann** on demythologizing, which the speaker uses to advocate for applying mythical insights into real life through ritual.
- The concept of **rites of passage** is discussed with examples spanning multiple cultures and emphasizing the structural patterns of these rituals.
- Discussion of the Eucharist as a sacrifice, contextualized within Christian theology and its distinct interpretation within the Catholic tradition.

The talk emphasizes that understanding and performing sacrifice in both liturgical and everyday contexts can serve as a profound practice of translating mythical and religious significances into tangible, daily experiences, thus nurturing community bonds and personal spiritual growth.

AI Suggested Title: "Essence of Sacrifice: Rituals, Myths, and Transformation"

Photos: 
AI Vision Notes: 

-

Notes: 

Aug. 1-5, 2016

Transcript: 

Good morning. In the name of the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit. Amen. The reading of the Gospel of today fits so very well into the context of our approach here during this retreat. I connected with a story by Father Anthony DeMello. I suppose you know his book, this comes from the book, The Song of the Bird, and I'm referring to the confession of Peter. Jesus asks his disciples, what do people say, who do people say I am? And then they give him various answers, and then he asks, and you, who do you say I am?

[01:03]

And Peter says, you are this. Christ, the son of the living God, and Jesus praises him and says, Peter, son of John, you are blessed because flesh and blood have not revealed this to you, but my Father in heaven has revealed it to you. says, today is a different situation. Jesus asks me, Anthony, who do you say I am? And I say, you are Christ, the Son of the living God, And Jesus says, oh, Anthony, you poor fellow, flesh and blood have revealed this to you, and you didn't have the patience to wait until my father in heaven would reveal it to you. This is a very important insight.

[02:08]

We have to find it by ourselves, and this is why we take every word, and that was also, of course, part of Damas's approach. Don't just mouth it. Don't just say what you have heard and then repeat it. Every parent can do that. Ask yourself, and wait, and have the patience to wait until God will reveal it to you, but ask, ask. And so we took these two basic words, God and I, the human. And we try to do what St. Benedict also says in the rule, that we should think what words mean. When he speaks about the oratory, for instance, he says, sit quod dichitur.

[03:12]

It should be what it's called. What is it called? Oratory. So it's not a storeroom, it's a place for prayer, oratory, you allow it to pray. Don't store anything. And he says to the abbot, the abbot should remember what he is called, abbot, father. So he always goes back to the word, what does this really mean? This is what we are asking ourselves here. That's really all we are doing. These two basic big, big words are much too much for a week, God and I. But at least we try to think them through. What does it really mean? In asking about the human being, we have these two great questions.

[04:16]

Who am I? And there we talked about the myth of creation, and what is life all about? And there we talked about the hero myth. And he always tells us, very prosaically put, that life is about dying into greater life over and over again. And now, we make a step, a further step, which the myth-makers already made, Thousands and ten thousands of years ago, when these myths were first told around the campfires, they felt that telling was not enough. Obviously, what is life all about?

[05:20]

It has to be translated into life. So it needs a translation. And at the time of Father Damasus, that was sort of the heydays. of what was called demythologizing. Rudolf Bultmann, a great Protestant theologian, was particularly promoting this. The great and legitimate concern of demythologizing was Don't just let it sit there in the midst, apply it in your life. But then it often went really the wrong way, where they just simply tried to say it in other words. If you tell a good story, it is much better than if you try to say it in prosaic words.

[06:27]

But this concern, how do I now bring the message of this myth, and in our case particularly the hero myth, how do I bring this answer to the question, what is life all about, into my daily life. How do I translate it into my daily life? And there they invented something which is called ritual. Ritual is the translation of the myth into daily life. That is why it is so important. And the particular ritual, which is really the ritual of all rituals, it's sort of the epitome of ritual, is sacrifice.

[07:32]

And this one is called a rite of passage. Rites of passage were these rituals that were celebrated whenever, in the course of a life, a young man or woman was The passing into life is already a passage, the birth, and puberty is a very special event. Many puberty rites are celebrated. And the introduction into society or into a particular part of society must celebrate, and of course marriage must celebrate as a rite of passage in order to become for a father or a mother, and then death was celebrated by rites of passage. But at the heart of every rite of passage, typically, is sacrifice.

[08:39]

So that's why we have to say more about sacrifice today. And what helps us understand sacrifice is that sacrifice translates the hero myth into ritual. Sacrifice is the translation of the hero myth into ritual. Now, one can show this this way. We saw that the hero myth has three phases. The first phase was that the hero, who tells us what life is all about, if we identify with the hero, is singing out for our identification with the hero. And then the hero goes out into the encounter with mystery, and that is the second phase.

[09:46]

It's the encounter with mystery, with that with which we as human beings have to deal, which we cannot comprehend, cannot control, but can and must understand by undergoing it. Understanding and undergoing belong together. Comprehending and overstanding belong together. That is the middle and the most central and important aspect of the hero myth, that dying. but a dying into fuller life, and therefore the third phase of the hero myth, where the hero returns to the community as life-bringer, greater fullness of life, celebration of life. Even in such simple forms as a little red riding hood that follows this pattern, there is the celebration of the grandmother and the hunter and

[10:51]

little girl and all the neighbors with that cake that she was originally bringing to the grandmother and a bottle of wine. And now we see, and this is the important step, that sacrifice. Of course, again, thousands of different forms of sacrifice, and I will illustrate it by telling you about a few. But sacrifice always has that same three-step pattern, and the first one is the offertory. We know that from the sacrifice of the Eucharist. The first is the offertory in which gifts are singled out. for identification, exactly what we said about the yirmith, fruit of the earth and work of human hands. So we bring ourselves to the altar when we bring bread and wine in the Eucharist.

[11:56]

This represents us, and it represents nature, fruit of the earth, and it represents culture, work of human hands. So everything human is represented thereby, and we are identified Then comes the consecration, and in the consecration it is made over to mystery, consecrated, made, put together with the sacred, consecrare, it's made sacred, it is handed over, and The gesture for this making over is the lifting up. We have the instinctive notion that the secret is higher than the other things, the higher things.

[12:59]

So this lifting up of the host, this lifting up of the chalice, There is a very important gesture in it, and of course, the connection with the death of our hero through the words. In the night before he died, before he was handed over, he gave himself, and he gave himself in the form of bread and wine, the reference to the death. The death of Christ is remembered, as St. Thomas Aquinas says, so that's the looking back to the history. It's remembered, it is celebrated, that's the present, and it is a token for our everlasting life, that's the future. And all of this comes together in this present moment of the consecration.

[14:01]

And then that leads over to the communion, and that corresponds to the hero coming back to the community as life-bringer. This feast, we celebrate this feast together with Christ, in Christ, and with one another, and with the whole world, with everything that was represented in the offertory. Work of human hands and nature, all nature, all culture, everything is included. in this celebration, and it is a real celebration, and it's a communal celebration. And so, to see this only as I am now privately, so to say, receiving the body of Christ, well, yes, I am receiving the body of Christ, because God loves me as if I were the only one there is, as Fr. Danvers is used to stress. But there's more to it than my personal

[15:03]

communion with God in and through Jesus Christ. There is communal celebration, and we should not forget that. We should always try and find also ever better ways to make this a communal expression of our celebration. Of course, the kiss of peace is one of those. It's right very close to the communion, comes directly before the communion, and expresses We celebrate together, just like at a birthday party you give one another hugs, so at this party it's a party. We give one another hugs as part of the celebration. Now it may help us to see that this Eucharist is really a sacrifice if we look at other sacrifices, because very often

[16:18]

In Christian theology, not in Catholic so much, not in Catholic at all, but in Protestant theology, and after all, they are all Christian brothers, and they are also trying to go deeply into the mysteries that we worship, it was at least denied that the Last Supper, as they call it, or the celebration of Christ's Last Supper, is a sacrifice. or sacrifice, that's what these heathens do, and we don't want to have anything to do with that. And that's one of the aspects of the beauty of the Catholic approach, that we include all that. Yes, of course, it's a sacrifice, and I hope that any A tribal member who would come in here would recognize it. I hope he'd celebrate it in such a way that they would recognize, yeah, this is a sacrifice like these sacrifices.

[17:23]

They would be much more Catholic than if you just do some hocus-pocus. And you know that the word hocus-pocus comes from hocus-corpus. It was a taunt. to this kind of magic that was celebrated there in the Eucharist. No, it's not magic, it's worship, it's sacrifice. So, maybe I tell you about a bloody sacrifice I witnessed. Actually, in Calcutta, in India, in a place in a temple, in the Kali temple, in which not very long ago, still in the 20th century, I was told human sacrifices were performed on that same altar. Well, thank God I didn't see a human sacrifice, but it was a very important experience for me to see a goat being sacrificed there.

[18:33]

It increased my appreciation of sacrifice, and it had exactly that same pattern. First you saw the family arriving on the rickshaw. That poor rickshaw carrier had to carry this whole family plus the goat. They were all sitting on that little wagon, father, mother, one or two children, and the goat. So they came to the temple, and then they arranged themselves, and they stood there, and the goat was in front. The father stood behind the goat and put his hands on the back of the goat. All the family stood around. You couldn't express the identification with this goat better than in this way. And the priest stood on the other side and held the head of the goat. And then they brought the goat to a little kind of little guillotine and

[19:35]

and it was chopped off, but not very quickly. There was a whole buildup, like in a circus where they have drums, and there were drums there, and they had this drum roll that got louder and louder and louder as it was building up to this chopping thing. In my case, it was particularly emphasized by the fact that right next to me was a little pickpocket. And I saw another man, whom I didn't know, who had a bag, and I saw the hand of this little pickpocket going into this bag. while this drum roll was, because everybody was watching the sacrifice, so he thought that was a safe time to go. And then the bang, and the head chopped off and falls off, and the pickpocket, the man had noticed it too, and grabs the head of the bag, and it's wiggling inside of the bag, so it was a real big bang.

[20:44]

But the encounter with death, the encounter with mystery there. And then the next step is that even though the Hindus are vegetarians, immediately they hang up the goat right then and there, they bleed it, they skin it, they cook it right there in the temple, and they have a big feast with it. It takes place right there with blood on the floor all around, but they celebrate, and this communal celebration was equally strongly expressed. But it isn't always so obvious, and so I would like to call your attention to two other sacrificial gestures. you would really recognize as sacrifice if you are alert to it, but they are barely noticeable.

[21:50]

And one of them is in China, A thousand, a hundred thousand times you can see that. When people start eating what we would call prayer before meals, they have their rice bowl, and everywhere they would do that. They take a little bit of rice, with three fingers they take a little bit of rice, So that's the offertory, just taking it, you know, because it is singled out as representing all that's in the bowl and representing all that feeds us. Take this little rice, then they lift it a little above the rim of the bowl, lift it up, make it over to the sacred. You might hardly notice it, but that's what it means. And then they eat it, and that's the communion.

[22:52]

So, in this very little gesture you have already And that is particularly good because it doesn't have to be a big bank sacrifice somewhere in a temple. It's what you do every day, right, at every meal you're doing. So that brings it already much closer into your daily life. Or in Greece, you will see, and maybe some of you have seen that. Then anybody, before they drink, while we would kind of lift up the glass and cheer, they would lift up the glass and flip it a little bit, and a drop of wine falls to the ground. Greek people would always do that, or at least any traditional people. Maybe not in the big cities, the Greek descent, I don't know that. But in Greece, they would always do that. And the draught that is jumping out of the glass when they make that little flip, that is the offertory.

[23:59]

You see, this little draught is set aside as representing the whole wine and everything that brings joy to us. then it falls to the ground. In this case, it's not lifted up to the sky, but the ground is also sacred, you know, take off your shoes, this is holy ground. And it is the ground from which mysteriously this wine grew, and then it's just as mysterious that wine should grow out of the earth, you know? So it's made over to mystery, and then they drink, and that's the communion. Then there's this joy of communion. Father Damascus used one of his favorite passages that he came back to many times was the second verse of the first chapter of Leviticus.

[25:04]

And there it says, when a man brings a sacrifice, when a man brings a sacrifice, And Father Damascus used to say, The Jewish sages say, unless a man brings a sacrifice, that is not a man. It's not a human being. And that makes us, to human beings, that we bring a sacrifice. And that was very important to him, that whole notion of sacrifice and making us human through sacrifice. And he would very often say—and, of course, that is in the context in which we have presented this here now and seen it in its—how it belongs together.

[26:05]

Unless a human lives what life is all about, you can barely call it a human. That's what makes us human, that we live what life, that we realize in our own lives and live it what is life all about. And the Hieronymus tells us that. It's through dying into life and the sacrifice Mixing the reality in our daily living, ritualizes it. And one aspect under which Father Damascus was also frequently speaking about sacrifice was he would tell us, you must sacrifice your Isaac. Do you remember that? He would always talk about, you must sacrifice your Isaac. And that is, of course, the story of the sacrifice of Abraham. How much more could somebody identify with the sacrificial gift than a father with his son?

[27:19]

And that is why Father Damos stressed that aspect very much when he told the story of Abraham. The voice of God says to Abraham, take your son. And that is not enough. It has to be rubbed in. Take your son, your only one. Abraham had already two sons, we were told at that time, but when it comes to sacrificing, when one child is in such danger, that is the only one that the father can even think about. Take your son, your only one, the one you love. Isaac. And when this name is out, every time we read it, that should really shake us almost the way it must have shaken Abraham, you know.

[28:20]

Imagine that. And then Twilight Damocles says, and that is what is the dearest to us, the nearest to us, what we most love. That needs to be again and again made over to God, made over to mystery, because death means being made over to mystery, and so healed. Because that is another aspect that we need to take into consideration, that sacrifice heals. Sacrifice is healing. In what way is sacrifice healing? First of all, we have to distinguish healing from curing.

[29:29]

Curing moves on a different level from healing. Curing is something external. Certainly, when we have a physical Pain or impairment? We certainly pray that that will be healed, you know, our leg or our foot or our tendon or whatever it be, or our stomach ulcers or whatever. We pray that it be cured, not only healed. But the cure may or may not take place. The healing can always take place. Prayers for cure are not always literally answered by curing. They're always answered. Prayers are always answered. There's the story of little girls, one of whom prayed for a particular doll

[30:41]

for Christmas. She wanted exactly that doll for Christmas. And she told it to all her friends, and all the girls knew she was praying to get that doll for Christmas. Well, Christmas came and went, and she did not get this doll. So the other girl said, well, God didn't hear your prayers. But the little girl said, yes, he did hear it. He just said no. And this is what we always have to take into consideration. When it comes to curing, God sometimes says no, and that has reasons which we cannot fathom. But when it comes to healing, it's always right. Healing is always right. Because healing is not a state. You see, health is not a state. It's nothing static. But healing is a way of living. a way of living and dying, living and dying.

[31:43]

There's no living without dying, no true living without dying. Living and dying, and that process is healed, that process, because if through sacrifice we enter into a deeper understanding again and again of this die and live, which we had in the hero myth, and acted out in sacrifice, then we are healed. It's a walking. To be healthy is a kind of walking. And walking is the process of losing your balance and finding your balance. If you do not have the courage to lose your balance, you can never walk. Because the moment you lift up one leg, you lose your balance. And then you put it down. and you're a little further ahead, and you lift the other one, you lose your balance and you put it down.

[32:48]

So walking, or living in the sense of being on the way, is always losing and finding your balance continuously. And in this sense of healing and sacrifice as healing, Father Damasus was very frequently referring to this, or at least I remember that it was very important, I don't know how often, but to me this really stuck in my memory, to the chapter 47 of Ezekiel. And we had that this morning, a reference to it this morning in the reading at vigils. So I thought, this is really, for the time it was breathing down my neck here, it couldn't fit better. I had planned to speak about this. He would speak about this story, the healing water is flowing out of the temper.

[33:57]

Sacrifice, the temper, the altar, our chapel, that is what he saw as the temper. And it was very important, another passage was very important to him, from the Psalms, I didn't understand anything until I entered the temple of the Lord. And when we enter the temple of the Lord, everything falls into place. We understand everything. And out of this temple, over the threshold, flows this healing water. Then the angel tells Ezekiel to measure it. At first it is only ankle deep, then it is knee deep, then again a thousand measures, and it is waist deep. and then another thousand measures, and then it is deep enough so that a human being has to swim.

[35:01]

And this was for them the interpretation. At that point, you are in deep water, you are deep in water, and you have to In order to swim, you have to lay down. So it's like a prostration. You have to lay down. You can no longer stand. You have to entrust yourself completely to the water when it is that deep. And only then, when you get into it and when you give up, so to say, you're no longer standing on your own two feet, but you entrust yourself fully to the water. Then comes the next step, then you are led to the shore, and there is then paradise. First of all, fish everywhere in the water, food on the trees, trees full of fruit, and the leaves are for the healing.

[36:06]

Leaves are for healing. So there is this healing through the water that flows from the temple. Healing comes through the life-giving power that emanates from the place of sacrifice, from sacrifice. often, very often, spoke about this healing. And there were three stories that he was coming back to often that I remember. And the first one was in John 5, fifth chapter, verse 6. In the fifth chapter, John tells about the healing of the paralytic at the sheep gate, at the ponds of Bethesda. To this day, there is the sheep gate there, and they have found, in relatively recent excavations,

[37:15]

that there were actually those seven ponds, these ponds were discovered, and they were healing ponds because there was a Roman temple to Asclepius, the god of healing, was there, and apparently that was already there. at the time of Jesus. It's a particularly interesting story. Peer Benoit, with whom I had the great blessing of having a tour of Jerusalem, said that Jesus may have actually gone into this Roman sanctuary, into this Eden sanctuary, and there performed his healing. But the important thing is that Jesus asks the man, do you want to be healed? That is what Thomas was emphasizing. When it comes to healing, we should ask ourselves, do you really want to be healed? After all, this man was prostrated by his sickness for 36 years.

[38:23]

But after 36 years, do you really want to be healed or are you here so long because you don't want to be healed? He says, I do not have a man, I don't have anybody that carries me into the water when the angel moves the water. That may or may not be an excuse, but the important thing is, do you really want to be healed? And after that comes the story of the centurion who asked Jesus to heal his son. Father Damascus stressed that three times this centurion is referred to in the story, and each time with a different title. The first time it says, the official asked. So he comes in his official position and asks of Jesus.

[39:27]

It's a very formal, official ask. Then Jesus says, go, just go. He doesn't perform any ritual. He just, go, your son is healed. And the father, in faith, he goes. And then it says, and the man realized. As an official, he asks very formally, as a man, as a human being, he realizes. A man brings a sacrifice, he realizes. And then, through this realization, the father believes. The official asks, the man realizes. That's a human reality. And then the father, then he becomes a father, because when we realize in faith, we become fathers. It's not just his family, but we are able to propagate this faith and to close over to others.

[40:38]

And the third story was in Mark 2, 11 and 12. 1 to 12, the first twelve verses, and particularly the ninth verse, that is the healing of the paralytic whom his friends let down through the roof, and therefore the Damasus stressed two aspects of the healing. First of all, that his friends brought him there. This man would have never been healed if he hadn't friends. So we have to help others towards this healing. We are responsible for others. There's not a private affair. And that harks back, of course, to the man at the pool who says, I have no man. Nobody carries me in the water. Well, this one had a man. Friends are very important for healing. But then, the end of it is that Jesus says, take your bed and carry it home.

[41:44]

So, what Father Damascus stressed was, that was his problem, that he was lying on this bed, and he doesn't get rid of this bed. He sticks with him. Don't think when you're healed, you're already rid of your problem. Only the difference is, before that you were helplessly lying on it, and now you have the strength to carry it. Don't expect that you walk away from it, or you're stuck with it, whatever your permanent problem is, but now you can carry it. That is the healing. That may also have to do with the healing and the curing. And in this way, we ponder these ways of healing, the power of the sacrifice, the power of the daily sacrifice that we celebrate in the Eucharist flows into our daily lives.

[42:51]

And so, for our homework, I would again ask you to complete a sentence. And the sentence reads, I let the healing power of the daily Eucharist flow into my life. I let the healing power of the Eucharist flow into my life. Bye. Then comes, how do I do? How do you do it? Obviously, you're doing it, but think about it. How do you really do it? That may help. You may have discovered your own way of doing it. And this evening we will speak about ways of doing it, but to prepare, ask yourself, how am I already doing it? So that you don't wait to be told, but don't let the Holy Spirit give this to you.

[44:03]

And of course, this celebrating the sacrifice of the Eucharist daily and this translating it into healing power for our moment-by-moment living is Realization is an expression, is a celebration of our life in God, in whom we live and move and have our being. So if he goes again with the doxology, that expresses that in God we live, we are also reminding ourselves every time we pray this doxology of living out of that mystery and being healed through that mystery. Glory be to the Father, through the Son, in the Holy Spirit.

[45:14]

As it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be, world without end. Amen. Thank you for your visits, and thank you for your questions that I have received. And don't wait. If you still want to ask a question or visit me, don't wait for the last moment, because on Sunday afternoon, I will be tied up. So it would be better to do it earlier. Thank you.

[45:46]

@Transcribed_v004
@Text_v004
@Score_JJ