Wisdom's Vision in Zen Practice
Welcome! You can log in or create an account to save favorites, edit keywords, transcripts, and more.
AI Suggested Keywords:
The talk delves into the concepts of wisdom and capacity, emphasizing the intricacies and contradictions inherent in Zen practice. The discussion explores how wisdom relates to vision and responsibility, implying that wisdom involves a deep sense of seeing and understanding, akin to the Vedas' concept of "one who has known." The exploration touches upon the practice of Sashin, highlighting the mental and physical challenges faced, the process of discovering a sustainable pace, and the importance of a non-deteriorating state of mind. Meritorious actions and their intrinsic connection to wisdom and separateness are examined. The talk concludes with reflections on how Zen stories and metaphors illustrate the interconnectedness and essential unity of all things, urging practitioners to observe their mental states with both gentleness and firmness.
Referenced Works
- Vedas (Rig Veda, Sanskrit): Mentioned as a parallel to the concept of wisdom, indicating one who has seen or known, thus linking wisdom to a profound, experiential knowledge.
- Wisdom Sutras: Referenced to indicate the practice of wisdom within Zen, despite the linguistic and conceptual challenges in defining wisdom.
- Joshu/Chao-chou Tsung-shen: Cited in anecdotes illustrating the understanding of Zen practice, particularly the idea of not seeking outside oneself and comprehending inner and outer boundaries.
- Sixth Patriarch’s Poem: Compared to Joshu's story, underscoring stages in Zen realization from maintaining a clear mind (mirror polishing) to understanding non-duality (no mirror, no dust).
- Garuda and Dragon Metaphor: Used to express the non-dual perspective of existence and the interconnectedness and unity of seeming opposites.
- Suzuki Roshi: Referenced as an exemplar of embodying wisdom and responsibility, highlighting a disciplined and undeteriorated state of mind during Sashin practice.
Key Concepts and Discussions
- Wisdom and Its Linguistic Roots: Wisdom is explored through its etymological links to vision and responsibility, suggesting that true wisdom encompasses a deep obligation to what one perceives.
- Sashin and Mind Deterioration: The practice of Sashin is discussed in terms of maintaining mental resilience, noting that physical pain can be managed when the mind remains steady and undisturbed.
- Interconnectedness and Boundaries: The talk repeatedly returns to the theme of interconnectedness, using analogies of hands and the interplay between light and darkness to illustrate that separateness is an illusion.
- Teacher-Student Relationship in Zen: Emphasized as a key element for cultivating wisdom and responsibility, with examples showing the dynamic and often challenging interplay between expectations and teachings.
- Practical Exercises to Understand Mental States: Suggested that practitioners should observe what causes their minds to deteriorate and learn to cultivate mental states that preserve clarity and composure.
This structured summary provides a comprehensive yet concise exploration of the central themes and references, enabling advanced academics to identify pivotal discussions pertinent to their studies in Zen philosophy.
AI Suggested Title: Wisdom's Vision in Zen Practice
AI Vision - Possible Values from Photos:
Side: A
Location: City Center
Possible Title: 7th day City Pr. P. Sesshin
Additional text: BR\nSF
@AI-Vision_v003
What I've been trying to talk about this Hashim is the background of our existence or the foreground of our existence and of course that's the real subject matter of Buddhism and it's by its nature and not by its non-nature. Not something we can actually talk about. In some ways it's too obvious to talk about. It's so obvious that, so obvious that
[01:05]
It's not polite to talk about it. It's embarrassing to talk about it. That's also extremely contradictory. And we're also, of course, you know, then we don't talk much about warm-hearted practice or love or wisdom, even though it's the wisdom sutras, still we don't talk about wisdom, so-and-so is wise, but actually you are practicing wisdom and I'd like to discuss what wisdom might mean.
[02:14]
This is a pretty important word in our society or in your life, you know. It's one of those really big words, wisdom. And I bet you, none of you have, almost none of you have ever looked it up in the dictionary or thought much about what could it possibly mean. Wisdom. Wise, dumb. I've always liked in India, you know, in America, of course it's gone out of business, but, or at least it's not being published. Our big magazine was Life. And in India, the big fiction magazine is Wisdom. Wisdom is one of those words which means everything.
[03:20]
If you do look it up, it of course means to see. And it's related to vision and advice, the vice part. But in addition to meaning to... it means both to see and what is seen. And it also has the meaning of to reproach, to reproach or to guard. or to watch out for, or to look at, or to guide, or seer. And it's the same, it seems to be the same word as Veda, Rig Veda, Sanskrit.
[04:35]
I guess that means something like one who has seen or one who has known. The known or the seen. I like the reproach part of it. Because the sense of a seer, I think, that sense of wisdom is one who takes responsibility for what you see. And that's a question in practice. Where do you drop your line of responsibility? There's another one. A capability which I've been using, or capacity I've been using.
[05:38]
Capacity is another word that means both sides of things. It comes from capable, which means something like your hand's full, or to take it with your hands, and from spacious, which has something to do with pace, or taking, or to open, to lie open. So it's to take with your hands and get everything that extends beyond your hands? Or where? Where does it end? Yesterday I was talking about, from one of your questions about Suzuki Roshi, And maybe I was a little misleading when I said that saschins are as painful.
[06:53]
My saschins, still, after 15 years or so, are as painful as a third saschin. I suppose physically that's true, but I found... But it's also not true that sessions are difficult for me because my mind doesn't deteriorate. I found, and it was maybe pretty closely related to, stop being grimacing, making those faces. when I discovered a pace by which I could get through Sashin. And that pace is closely, maybe that pace is the first step toward your mind not deteriorating.
[08:08]
And you can do some experiments and try to deteriorate your mind if you want. One good way to experiment with mind deterioration is to start with self-praise. You just said today, I don't know, maybe, by the way, when I said to follow your exhale only, I didn't mean the whole session. Several of you have asked me about that. No, I just meant to try it out. I can see you going through your work week next week gasping for your inhale. Why are you gasping?
[09:18]
So, your experiment can be... I want you to really get into praising yourself. Think of something that you really do deserve praise for, not just something you're making up, something you're pretty glad you did. you're pretty satisfied that you did it. And you can tell yourself, yes, I did that, that's not so bad. And you'll feel some warm feeling. And then you can add a little fuel to the fire. And you can think, yes, not only did I do that. Also, yes, I helped that person. And I said such and such, or I influenced such and such, and it came out all right, or whatever. And you'll feel better and better for a while, and then you'll start to deteriorate, and you'll notice that you aren't not so alert, or you kind of stumble, or actually you're in a kind of cruddy, cruddy state of mind.
[10:31]
You can see the same deterioration, you know. If you go, say you go to the beach, to Muir Beach or Stinson Beach, and you lie in the sun, it's really wonderful. The sun is so like soft hands, and it's dark, you face the sand, and very private. But two days, or three days, or ten days, You start to deteriorate. You can't do it. Drugs are the only answer. Ten days on the beach, you couldn't make it alone without a little help from your friends. So anyway, you can watch your mind deteriorate. Or the same thing, you know, you have some flesh and fantasy, some positive fantasy, or some dreamy, as someone said, state of mind, and you feel pretty good, but if you notice actually, the quality of your mind starts to deteriorate.
[11:51]
So frankly, you know, Sashins became possible for me, when my mind, I no longer get tired, or exasperated or impatient with session. Each period or the end and the beginning and middle were just the same. So even though my legs hurt like hell, my mind didn't mind. And you'll find, as you must have found, that when your mind deteriorates, then the discomfort signals are overwhelming. The pain is always chipping away at your state of mind, that's true, but you can get to the point where your mind doesn't deteriorate, and then Satsang is just like everyday life. An undeteriorated state of mind, I would also say, is similar to merit.
[12:58]
not an accumulation, it's more like returning to the source or letting go. This is how contradictory. If you let go or you drop away ideas, or instead of trying to improve things, improve a situation, you're able to let go of a situation. The sense in many stories, Zen stories, of he resumed the source or he resumed the origin sometimes means emptiness, that contradictory state of mind is actually fullness, or the capacity for experience, or merit. To describe it as merit describes it as something, that's actually
[14:02]
more like the absence of something. But you do, it is good for other people. Now, to try to talk about responsibility for what you see, I want to talk about your being a representative. I don't know if this is a good way to make sense of this, You are a representative of man or woman, and you're a representative of Zen Center, and you're a representative of the Midwest or someplace, Los Angeles, and you're a representative of the human race, etc. I suppose, in that sense, wisdom would be someone who's always aware that they're a representative of the, I don't know, of sentient beings or of the capacity of human beings.
[15:12]
So when I said I love Suzuki Osho, you know, that's true and just like that, but to express it more accurately, I was so glad and grateful that someone who was a good representative of the human race existed. What a relief to find a few good representatives because usually one doesn't find such good representatives. Most people are so scared to be alive or qualified about being alive or not sure they really deserve to be human beings or other people don't like them or they don't like other people They haven't got their walking papers yet, or approvals. It's okay to be a person, you know. They haven't got those papers yet.
[16:15]
They don't know where to apply. Most people are like that. The seeker actually knew where to apply. And he was acknowledged by his teacher. as a good representative of the lineage and of the human race, the human dead heat, the human star. Maybe it should be the human relay race. but also there's the feeling in someone like Suzuki of reproach. And it's partly reprojection, partly it's you expect your teacher to expect of you what you expect of yourself.
[17:33]
I think that's right. So you feel uneasy around your teacher, you know, because you know how you don't fulfill what you expect of yourself. And you project that he knows or she knows that, too, and probably he or she does. So there's that sense of, in someone like Svidriga of that projection, of that person being a kind of mirror of what we feel our capacity is. And also it's not just a projection, there's somebody really there who is looking at you. So also there's some fear or reservation
[18:37]
And if that makes you angry, you know, maybe your teacher will try to get you to diminish your expectations. If you can handle such expectations, maybe your teacher will allow it to occur. It's some interplay, mostly from the student side. And also, you know, speaking about Sashin, It's not just... It's true when I feel you should be able to go through what it is to be a human being, a representative of the human race, and what we experience in sickness and various kinds of agony.
[20:12]
Sugreshi, I remember saying, many people have had their heads cut off by a sword. You should be prepared for that. I think that's true. And don't think you're going to escape life, or escape a sword. Some of you may not escape a sword, or a disease, or someone called me this morning. I had to call a hospital, it makes sense. I said, is so-and-so in the hospital? And they said, we have no information on that patient, on such a patient. And I said, you have no information on such a patient? They said, we have no information on such a patient.
[21:15]
And I said, you have no information on such a patient? There's no one by that name in the hospital? She said, I didn't say we didn't have such a patient. I just said we have no information on such a patient. I said, oh, a no-info patient, which I found out before actually. There was this no-info patient. And it's somebody who has been trying to contact me the last few days. I don't know them. I guess we have not met, but anyway, this person's been trying to contact me. And a few nights ago, someone came to the house he'd never met before and shot him through the head and through the stomach. I don't know what the situations were.
[22:16]
Perhaps he's in some situation that expected it. Jay, you know, was of course shot in the alley up here. So he's had a couple operations and I guess he's going to survive. But talking with him it sounded like there was a bullet in his head and he was very unable to sustain in reality. It wasn't confusion but some kind of loss of energy. You don't know whether you'll escape a bullet or what actually you don't. So to my mind Zen and Sashin is pretty easy. This is pain. The pain of Sashin is pain you can stop at any time by uncrossing your legs. It helps a little anyway. Or it's not really damaging you or not too much.
[23:18]
It's not really a serious problem. So some warrior feeling, warrior being one who can face the worst, some warrior feeling, That's all. That you can face things. Face, face. this wisdom to see. But the problem is we can't see. Often seers in literature are blind people, not only because they're often quite alert, but also because of this play of to see, and you can't see.
[24:40]
So, by background, I have some reservation about expressing things this way, but I'll do it anyway. There's light and dark. There's A plus B, and then there must be C. To say something, there must be a background or a contrast. If you have an object, it creates space. There can't be an object without space. If you had an object without space, you'd have a solid iron wall. So there has to be some boundary, or you can't say it's an object. We wouldn't be here if there was no boundary for us to move around in. So there are lots of boundaries. Someone said that an atom is a curved space locked into itself, so things can't pass through it.
[26:01]
I don't know about that, but... Anyway, we have lots of boundaries, all kinds of boundaries which allow us to have these interrelationships of poison oak, and blood vessels and such like. But what is the background? If there's also, we pose the object and then pose space, what's the background of the object in space? Or, you know, if you think about of outer space? Is its fundamental nature darkness? Because the light is something from the sun? No, I'm not trying to say anything scientific.
[27:04]
I'm just giving you some suggestion in a direction I want, in this direction. If there's a sun, The sun is some object, so maybe it has a beginning and an end, and there's light. So the light may have a beginning and end. So what's before light? Darkness? Maybe darkness. But if you go out in outer space, there's nothing but light, I think. I don't know exactly, but probably nothing but light. You have to get behind an object to find darkness. You have to get in the shadow of the earth to find darkness. So actually, you can say darkness is the fundamental, but it takes two objects to make darkness, the sun and something else. So is the fundamental stuff darkness or light?
[28:11]
Maybe light is everywhere. Or maybe even if there's darkness, there's something everywhere. Or is there everywhere? Where is everywhere? I was talking about hands yesterday. You have two hands which you see as separate. But your hands are of course joined, like here. They're always joined. Your hands are not separate at all. Two hands clap. So, you know, but where does your hand end? This is, according to dictionary, it ends there. But hand, we call that the hand, but yet, where does it end? So your hands are always joined.
[29:19]
There's only one hand. One big hand which had some problem and drooped to make my body. Drooped. A hand that drooped. Yet we experience it as separate. And we can pick up things, which we can't do so easily with the other ends of the hand. So we think that our hands are separate but they're joined. And we think the object is separate but is it separate? Or your hand. Is your hand really separate from mine, or is your hand also joint to mine, the same way these two hands are joint?
[30:25]
So, the hands are separate, and yet their background, say, is that they're not separate. Then, my body is separate, but what's the background of my body? some darkness or something you can't see. You know, from my window upstairs, I can watch the shadows of the clothes in the line going up and down the building, racing up and down.
[31:51]
The clothes are going like that and the shadows went up and down the side of the building. I guess I'm separate from the shadow. I can't go racing up the side of the building trying to chase it. And I guess the clothes are separate from the shadow. But to me, there is related... my own seeing is that they're as related as my two hands are always related. I don't have any problem with them being separate. This is, of course, what Mr. Yellow Dragon was trying to express when he said, Garuda and dragon, he's identifying with the dragon which is slithering along.
[32:59]
You don't see the dragon. You see a red-striped snake, you don't see the dragon. He said, what about a Garuda? And then he changes, you don't see the Garuda. He said, the Garuda will eat him. He said, well, I'll be well fed. In that story, this is the dragon and this is the Garuda. The Garuda is the left hand and the dragon is the right hand. This is the man without measurement, that you can't measure, which means also an undeteriorated state of mind. So, you'll see the many ways your mind, as you practice Sashin, you'll stop giving up You'll stop trying to gain something or accomplish something and you'll just notice what causes your mind to deteriorate – thinking, self, praise, you know.
[34:14]
In fact, most kinds of thinking cause your mind to deteriorate. And this is another way of saying leaking. Your state of mind will deteriorate. And you will be able to find out, if you're sensitive enough, what kind of thinking doesn't cause your mind to deteriorate. What kind of happening in your sasheen allows that accumulative feeling state of mind where it's almost too much, you can't face it and you think of anything to break the spell, break the the heat you feel. Too much, you're afraid you'll burn up your friends, burn up yourself. So anyway, you see what causes your mind to deteriorate.
[35:28]
And what doesn't? And you'll find the kind of thinking which doesn't cause your mind to deteriorate is very powerful thinking, very compassionate thinking. Thinking like, you know, maybe someone said to me, if there's only a finite number of ways your hands can meet, if there's only a finite number of ways the teacher and disciple can meet, That's true. And that's also all been figured out, but I won't explain it to you. I'd rather you figured it out. But there are only certain kinds of questions that can be asked, certain kinds of answers, answers which use things, except answerable. And certain ways in which there are real possibilities, even though I would say the teacher-disciple relationship is the most open relationship you can have.
[36:35]
Still, there's only certain possibilities, and your skill, in a way, as a student, is to discover those possibilities and make use of in the story of Joshu, again, about the dust. Someone says to Joshu, Where does the dust come from? And he said, It comes from outside.
[37:43]
And the monk said, Why in such a nice, clean monastery, or in a good monastery, is there dust? does dust appear? And he of course said, there goes another one. Now this is very interesting. I think this story is interesting and if not more truly typical Zen story than the Sixth Patriarch, you know, poem. I would say that there's a kind of... the levels you go through in your attempt to realize Zen practice, or something like those poems.
[38:46]
First there's a mirror and you're trying to polish it, trying to keep the dust off it. or you're trying to do zazen by rubbing a tile, hitting a horse. But at some point you find out that to depend on zazen is the same as to seek outside yourself. So, there's a second stage which is the second poem. which is there's no mirror and no dust and nowhere for anything to alight. But third stage is like Yoshi. Where does the dust come from? It comes from outside. Why is there dust? Oh, there goes another one.
[39:53]
One deals with the, shall we say, I don't know if you can, it's not, I can't say this exactly, but one deals with the outside as inside and the other, Joshi's, deals with the inside as outside. When he says, there goes another one, he's thinking maybe at his stomach. They come from outside, but this is a very good story, an accurate story, a good way to answer such a question. Just simply, anyone can understand it. Where does the dust come from? It comes from outside. But only someone whose eye is open can understand what he means.
[41:08]
Inside and outside, boundaries. What is the background of our existence? Or foreground of our existence? where our hands are joined. Sound of one hand. You have different necks.
[43:11]
Some of you have long necks. Some of you have fat necks. Some of you have red necks. Some of you have bumpy necks. Your own, my own experience of my neck and your experience of your neck are identical. When you wash your neck and I wash my neck, there isn't much difference. So this ability to stop treating your hands as separate, always, and also recognize that it's one hand, always joined.
[44:11]
And it's a rather crude example, but... That ability is something... It's a kind of secret. That you want to tell everyone, but you can't tell everyone. You can't find the opportunity when they'll listen. So what a teacher does is always waiting for the opportunity when they'll listen, when their throat chakra opens up, when their mind has not deteriorated
[45:29]
for one year or two years. And there's some aroused receptivity. And then there's often nothing to tell, often a refusal to tell. There's some Zen stories. There's a famous one of Zen. He's going to some some family's house where someone's died. So he walks in, he hits the coffin. I won't stay alive, I won't stay dead. And the other guy, his attendant, says, what did you mean? He goes, I won't say. I won't say. So he got, this man, Dawu, got mad at him. and said, after they were leaving, it's interesting, it's very interesting that he could get so excited about it.
[46:39]
And he was so excited about it, he said, you don't tell me, I'm going to hit you. And he said, even if you hit me, I won't tell you. bleeding down. So, I won't say, I won't say. So, he said, the teacher said to his disciple, after he was bleeding, you know, he said, you better get out of here or the director of the monastery is going to be rather angry when he finds out about it. So, the head of the abbot helped this disciple and hid him, escaped, because the other monks quite upset and would, of course, take in some action. So he went somewhere else. And later he understood. Horses cross, donkeys cross.
[48:01]
Treating things, how do you treat things in this way? Not intellectually. What did he mean? What kind of person was Joshu? Can we understand what kind of person Joshu was? Horses crossed, donkeys crossed. There goes another one. when your state of mind no longer deteriorates, which is what you're learning how to do in Sashin, why pain is so useful.
[50:00]
Find out how not to have your mind deteriorate. you can begin to take responsibility for everything you see, or know—this is wisdom—to know, know everything you see, as yourself. to know how to make use of its separateness, to know how to make use of your left hand and right hand. To make use of its separateness, you know, instead of bemoaning separateness, how to make use of separateness.
[51:07]
Can you see yourself as 64? Left hand and right hand. thrown up into the universe on a black cushion. Maybe when I look around the Zendo I see one hand after another, no head, just a big hand on each cushion. You can rearrange it and put a face on it if you want. So the rest of the sasheen, not so much time to go.
[53:18]
Let's sit with our state of mind. Be gentle with your state of mind and yet extremely firm with your state of mind. Find out that subtle guide of when it deteriorates and when it doesn't deteriorate. Not when you feel good or bad because too much good deteriorates it, too much bad deteriorates it. Find out how it deteriorates and maybe experience your life as a free-for-all with everyone.
[54:24]
Not a fight, but kind of abandon, I don't know, discipline, we have some discipline, but kind of abandon, as if everything may shift in front of you, or be snatched up away from you, or it may all dissolve MEGAWAR!
[55:36]
@Transcribed_v004
@Text_v005
@Score_84.06