You are currently logged-out. You can log-in or create an account to see more talks, save favorites, and more.
Embracing Earthquakes: Zen's Interconnected Truth
AI Suggested Keywords:
The talk explores Zen philosophy through the lens of experiencing interconnectedness during a significant event—a recent earthquake. It emphasizes embracing both the oneness and individuality inherent in Zen practice, the nature of truth as per Buddhist teachings, and how pivotal moments can lead to a deeper understanding of the true Dharma. The discussion integrates the teachings on the nature of emptiness and interconnectedness, highlighting the need for awareness and the practice of being present in every moment, with reference to Dogen Zenji's vows and teachings.
Referenced Works and Teachings:
-
Dogen Zenji's "Ehe Koso": The vow emphasizes hearing the true Dharma without doubt, underscoring a practice of openness and presence to comprehend the transient nature of reality.
-
Suzuki Roshi's Teachings: Insights into the transition from dualistic to non-dualistic understanding, where "form is emptiness and emptiness is form," illustrate an integration of mind and body in Zen practice.
-
Marshall McLuhan's "Global Village" Concept: Used to highlight societal interconnectedness akin to Zen's teaching of interdependence, suggesting modern media's role in unifying global consciousness.
-
Sangha Kaya: A teaching in Buddhism emphasizing the oneness of individual and universal experience, demonstrating the non-separateness of existence.
The talk invites a deep reflection on maintaining awareness through everyday experiences, viewed as opportunities for profound connection and understanding of the true Dharma.
AI Suggested Title: Embracing Earthquakes: Zen's Interconnected Truth
Speaker: Katherine Thanas
Additional text: Avery #5250
@AI-Vision_v003
I suppose many of you read the same item I saw in the newspaper about the new t-shirts. Thank you for not sharing where you were when the earthquake hit. And I appreciated this because every once in a while it got to be too much. And I mentioned this to somebody. And he said, oh no, we should put out one that says, thank you for sharing... where you were when the earthquake hit American therapeutic expressive association or something. There was obviously two points of view of whether we've talked too much about it or whether we need to continue talking about it and sharing our experience and integrating our experience. and including each other in what we have been through together. So I was thinking, well, which way shall I go this time?
[01:56]
And have we already passed that line where people are a little saturated? I noticed on the newspapers and TV, it's a little bit like everybody wants to get back to normal now. And the headlines are a little different than the news. You hear something else besides people collapsing and moving their homes and what can go. But I need to share with you I need to continue working myself with the issues that came up for me these past 10 days or so. So I think this will be some of both. I found, I happen to be on Highway 17. It's pretty close to the epicenter.
[03:08]
And the thought that came to my mind, I was suddenly in an altered reality. How did I miss knowing how I got here? Wasn't I paying attention? Had I fallen asleep on the highway and I suddenly woke up and my tires were all flat? And the trees were shaking and the leaves were going and I couldn't control my car. And I was gradually being moved over to the right. And I knew I didn't have any control of my car. Even though I was still hanging on to the steering wheel and acting as if I did. And the thought, I wasn't afraid for some reason, but thoughts that came into my mind was, how did I miss getting, knowing how I got here? You know, there's The work in Buddhism is to be aware, to be present, to know the transition, know the moment and the transition.
[04:11]
Anyway, I was glad that that was my thought. How did I get here? And this is interesting. I'm suddenly in a typhoon. And now, two days later, two days after that my thought was how do I stay open to what happened to my experience how do I not slip back into life as usual ads on the TV with the quality of voice again The quality of voice just different from the newscasters, the reporters who had been on the radio for a day and a half or so telling us where the Red Cross shelter was.
[05:17]
I was down in the carnival area telling us where the Red Cross shelter was and that power coming on and off and where gasoline stations might be that were open and just in helpful information. And suddenly... As things began to get back to normal, there was an ad slipped in. And I thought, yes, that's how we usually live. Talking at each other, you know? Talking with each other from a very deep place. And it's the teaching of Buddhism that whatever happens in this reality is truth. The earthquake is truth, as we all know. It's truth in the material world, and our experience of it is a very deep truth, very deep truth.
[06:26]
And the opening, the very deep, opening that we felt with each other, and the accompanying fatigue that so many of us experience, is an important truth to fully know. It's also the teaching of Buddhism that you can't hang on to anything. If we try, we're always trying with our minds to capture something that we like about our life or about ourselves, our experience, and to reject what we don't find so satisfying. But the truth is,
[07:28]
All of it. Truth is what has happened and is happening, whether we like it or not. And we create a suffering for ourselves by choosing, picking and choosing, and rejecting and accepting, grabbing, identifying, preferring. Dogen Zenji, our patron saint, the Japanese teacher who brought our tradition from China to Japan, and who left us a tremendous legacy of very profound teaching, said in something called the Ehe Koso the vow of Dogen Sanju.
[08:36]
I vow with all beings from this life on throughout countless lives to hear the true Dharma. And upon hearing it, let no doubt arise. So what I want to talk about a little today is hearing the true Dharma. And it's not easy to hear the true Dharma. And staying open to listen. Always staying open to listen. And I think that's a way of talking about integrating what's happened that doesn't hang on to it, that doesn't try to, okay, now I'll try to keep remembering where I was at 5.04 and how it felt.
[09:45]
I'll try not to forget that so then I get irritated and angry and rushed and anxious. I'll still remember that and I'll be a nice person. We don't function like that. Trying to do something like that denies who we are in the moment, in the arising of reality now. So, I can't hang on to 504. Aren't those 15 seconds interesting? Those 15 seconds we'll never forget. How many other 15 seconds in our lives are so vivid for us that we won't forget them? Not so many. Not so many when someone... is dying, or has died, or some of us have gotten, or we have gotten some diagnosis at the end, something that really shocks us, stops us, stops the small mind's obsessive thinking.
[10:59]
It's interesting, isn't it? Those 15 seconds, you won't forget. Perhaps we can't hang on to them. They're there. They're already part of our body. They're not in our mind. They're in our body. And so how do we make these 15 seconds, how can we find ourselves listening to the true Dharma in each 15 seconds? And it's work. We'll be fatigued a little bit, I think. Because part of us wants to close it off and get back to our unconscious way of being. Everything's on automatic. Don't have to think. It's automatic response. But the vitality. Richness.
[12:00]
And authentic knowing of our life that we experience with those 15 seconds is something we want to stay with. Our deep, inmost request wants to live from that moment. By the way, I've heard a couple of stories that may interest you. I've got my sharing t-shirt on there. There were three young men surfing off the shore at Aptos. And they noticed that there were three dolphins that had come and were in the water next to them, kind of hanging around. They had a sense they were being protected by the dolphins. And someone else down in that area who has the habit of riding, who works at the university in Santa Cruz, and he rides his bicycle down the campus, which is on the hill.
[13:17]
And there's a place where he stops and just enjoys the scenery. And from this place, you see the city and the curve of the coastline all the way down to the Monterey Peninsula. And it's quite beautiful, and he enjoys just looking at that. And last, on that Tuesday, that's where he was. He's just stopped when the earthquake hit. And he said, everything began to move. all the hills and buildings and the trees. And the leaves, which normally you only see one side of the leaves, the trees, they were shaking and you saw the underside. A whole different pattern of color all around him. It was very, very beautiful. And the whole vista was very beautiful.
[14:21]
So, there was terror There was fear and there was confusion and there was some joy. And in the words of the chant that we do every other morning here, the merging of different communities, reality is the merging or the oneness of difference. our particular individuality, our particular independent form and unity, merging of difference and unity, our oneness, our identity with everything.
[15:38]
And the truth isn't the oneness side of our independent side, that we're independent. It's true, each of us exists as a particular form. The truth isn't the side of the ocean, you know, wave and ocean, that we're all one life, the life of Buddha, Buddha nature, absolute reality. truth of interdependence, interconnectedness, the truth that we all felt so profoundly. The truth isn't one or the other, according to the Sangha Kaya, the teaching of Buddhism. The truth is the oneness of our individual life and the common life, oneness, or absolute identity with
[16:43]
We use a word like emptiness to express interconnectedness, non-separation. We're empty of separate self, and therefore we are full of everything. So using an expression, I vow to hear the true Dharma, gives me a way on each moment to pay attention to the Dharma which is both sides. You can't go around saying, everything is one, we're all one, without noticing each uniqueness, the way the universe expresses itself at each location.
[17:48]
Each of us is a location where the universe manifests, where all the causes all the elements of existence arise and something happens. It can be a happy thought and it can be a mean thought. It can be very petty, it can be competitive, it can be whatever, whoever it is we are. That's what the universe is bringing up at that location. How in the midst of whatever is coming up here, to not forget the side of emptiness, the true Dharma. That happy thoughts are just thoughts, the same way that mean thoughts are just thoughts.
[18:52]
And to let it all flow, arise and pass away, without grabbing the thoughts that we like and without feeling bad and trying to disguise or reject or not notice or feel guilty about the thoughts that we don't like, thoughts that bring up the dark side of our being. nine or ten days after the quake, here we are with this deep memory of a shared experience of dropping beyond limited mind and body into a communal experience, really talking to our neighbors. You know, the idea that this is a global village. I think Marshall McLuhan said media have made this a global, the world a global village.
[19:57]
You know, we are totally dependent on each other. I had a new muffler put on my car yesterday. Somebody had to make that muffler, and somebody had to weld it, and somebody had to build the building and pay the rent and hire all the people so that I could drive in and buy a new muffler. Normally, we take for granted that we have these functional relationships with each other. I pay some money and put something on my car and we exchange a piece of paper and that's it. And for many of us, we've gotten so used to the... anonymity of the big city life, that we are only in touch with that functional, the role aspect of our relationship.
[21:00]
But we've known, you know, that touch the heart. Sometimes we pray for the role that we are in our lives. that each of us is an expression of absolute truth, absolute being. Absolute Buddha nature. Each of us, we say, is this absolute Buddha. And when we meet each other from that place, which we have done, coming from deeper satisfaction. You know some deeper satisfaction.
[22:07]
I sat with a small group in Carmel, and the night of the quake, somebody said, after we We didn't know the dimensions of the quake at that time at all. But there they were sitting by candlelight when I arrived. And after we talked a little bit about the quake, somebody said something about, what do I do about my mind that's always thinking and dancing? I know I'm not supposed to be thinking, but I'm always thinking. And... It's not exactly that we're not supposed to be thinking. Thinking here is a metaphor for the expression of our individual separate self. But when thinking is happening, we should know, practice with, know the other side of thinking
[23:13]
Which is that while we're sitting inside and thinking, there's also not-thinking going on. And that not-thinking is what was going on among us after the earthquake. There was a kind of not-thinking connection that we had with each other. Regardless of the thoughts, there was something beyond the separations of our normal mind and body. And Suzuki Roshi has a very beautiful way of talking about this that I found helpful. He says, when you find it difficult to stop your mind, while you're sitting and when you are still trying to stop your mind this is the stage of form is emptiness and emptiness is form but while you're practicing in this dualistic way more and more you will have oneness with your goal
[24:35]
When your practice becomes effortless, you can stop your mind. This is the stage of form is form and emptiness is emptiness. To stop your mind does not mean to stop the activities of your mind. It means your mind pervades your whole body. Your mind follows your breathing. With your full mind, you form the mudra in your hands. With your whole mind, you sit with painful legs without being disturbed by them. This is to sit with that gaining idea. At first we feel some restriction in our posture, but when we're not disturbed by the restriction, we have found the meaning of emptiness is emptiness.
[25:45]
So when we're trying to hold on to ten days ago, trying to be one with what, trying to see the emptiness in that part, contacts with people, trying to see the absolute in each person, that's dualistic. It's a good practice. We have to do it. But it's a little dualistic because we're trying to do something. We're making some special effort. When we're just in the activity without trying to convert it to something else. We just meet whatever happens. If we have an ugly thought, we have an ugly thought. If we have a beautiful thought, we have a beautiful thought. If we have a beautiful feeling, that's a beautiful feeling.
[26:49]
If we're self-centered and angry and rejecting, we're just totally in that. That's the stage of form is form and emptiness is emptiness. And that's when we're just in each moment. We go through form as emptiness in order to get to form as form. You must be true to your own way until at last you actually come to the point where you see it's necessary to forget all about yourself. We can't force ourselves to the point where we see that it is necessary to forget all about ourselves. But we can make our clearest and best effort
[27:55]
to listen as deeply as we can to the deep resonance of the Dharma, to hear the true Dharma. And the true Dharma, for many of us, for many years, is hearing small mind and behind it, big mind. Small mind, self-centered view of reality, and big mind, reality are not attached to small view. You know, another way of talking about this is like karmic self and dharmic self. There's our karmic self. That's what I've been talking about, you know. small mind that thinks it's driving, that has plans for itself and has direction and has goals and wants to do zazen in order to get someplace, get something.
[29:05]
And dharmic self is the arising of phenomena without the label of need or love. Even though Catherine is arising in the phenomena, Catherine is just a location. It's no different from any other location in which the Dharma is arising. And we can only We only really can be with each other completely, totally, without injury, when we meet in our dharmic nature, dharmic self.
[30:13]
When we meet in our karmic manifestations. And by the way, these happen simultaneously, just to confuse the puzzle a little. Karma and dharma arise together. They're not tested. Same event can be seen from the point of view of karma, from the point of view of dharma. When we look at it, when we see our life, From karma we see obstruction and hindrance and difficulties and problems, and we see that we can't quite communicate. When we see from dharma, when we meet from a place of no-self, non-attachment to our point of view, our perspective, our emotional reality,
[31:18]
our truth, just you. No hindrance there. No obstruction. Complete unity. Merging of difference and unity says the mind of the great sage of India is intimately communicated between us and him. his mind intimately communicated, her mind intimately communicated between India and China. That kind of communication, intimate, no gap communication, no self, got in the way. Nobody tried to say to somebody, get this. Those minds both experienced realities fully in their own location. Same reality, slightly different location.
[32:22]
And we know when we're coming from that ground of reality, not attached, when we're with somebody who's very sick, or someone who's dying, and we're just putting ourselves in the place to help the person and to breathe with the person, without any idea of helping or being useful or trying to feel good about what we're doing, just being in that place. That's a taste of no-self, dharmic relationship. When we join our breathing with someone else's breath, that's dharmic relationship. And it's not so easy. And that's, I think, where the 15 comes in. Because we have layers of resistance and echo to run down.
[33:36]
of hearing the true Dharma, the truth of our absolute interconnectedness, of absolute truth, being, person, true expression of universal energy, universal life. When we know each other and know ourselves in that way, comes very deep satisfaction, very deep satisfaction in our lives. And there's some deep necessity to do this work, deep necessity. to meet ourselves and each other in this way.
[34:50]
Not just because we live in earthquake country. Earthquake country is a wonderful place that we practice in, isn't it? But it helps. We practice this way, you know, in Iowa or wherever the earth isn't shaking. Like the Roshi once said, that we should always walk as if we weren't sure if our foot would land, if we weren't sure where the ground would be. And I thought of that last week. That was pretty good. That we should meet our life not knowing the most obvious, not being so sure. Not being so confident or so safe or predictable. And when we meet each other, not knowing who each other is, not knowing who we're going to meet, our life becomes more vivid.
[35:59]
The leaves turn and see the underside of the leaves. And the dolphins are swimming all around. you
[36:28]
@Transcribed_UNK
@Text_v005
@Score_81.54