August 2016 talk, Serial No. 00181

00:00
00:00
Audio loading...

Welcome! You can log in or create an account to save favorites, edit keywords, transcripts, and more.

Serial: 
MS-00181

AI Suggested Keywords:

AI Summary: 

The discussion explores the concept of the "double realm," a term borrowed from poet Rainer Maria Rilke, to illustrate the unity yet dual aspect of human existence: temporal and eternal. This idea underpins a broader commentary on living a monastic life, deeply interwoven with the gospel's teachings focused on community, humility, and non-violence, contrasting sharply with societal structures driven by rivalry and fear. References include:

- Rainer Maria Rilke, mentioned for the term "double realm" and his influence on monastic thinking.
- Joseph Campbell's "A Hero with a Thousand Faces," used to discuss common patterns in hero myths and their implications for understanding human experiences and narratives.

The talk expands these ideas into a broader reflection on community living as a realization of Jesus' vision, contrasting it with contemporary societal structures that often prioritize power and competition over communal welfare and spiritual integrity. This narrative is further enriched by examples from Christian scripture and monastic traditions that emphasize service, hospitality, and the simple, profound act of living in accordance with divine principles, exemplified through Christ's life and teachings.

AI Suggested Title: "Double Realm: Monastic Living in the Eternal and Temporal"

Is This AI Summary Helpful?
Your vote will be used to help train our summarizer!
Photos: 
AI Vision Notes: 

AI Vision - Possible Values from Photos:
Speaker: Daivd St. Rast
Location: undefined
Possible Title: Retreat 2016 conf. #6
Additional text: maxell, CD-R Music

@AI-Vision_v002

Notes: 

Aug. 1-5, 2016

Transcript: 

Today's Vespers made me appreciate how warmly I've been welcomed here. how good and how blessed we meet you, and brothers, I want to take this opportunity to thank you again for that warm reception and love. In the name of the Father, and the Son, and the Holy Spirit. So this morning we spoke about one of the two great myths, the creation myth. We are speaking about myths because they give us a wonderful opportunity to go really deep because they are the great answers to the great questions of the human heart.

[01:08]

It's a great poetic answer to one of the great questions of the human heart. And how this will all tie in also with monastic living, I've tried to point it out step by step, but I think sort of the full picture emerges, of course, only in the course of our sharing here. So what was the most important aspect of This morning's presentation was, first of all, that we live in this double realm. I didn't mention this word, double realm. It is a word that was coined by the poet Rainer Maria Rilke, who was a very important part of Danvers' history.

[02:15]

We'd often quote him, and that's one of his key terms. And it means a unity. It's not two realms or two halves of one realm. It is one realm of which we can see two different things under two different aspects. In our case, this double realm is our human life here on Earth, and under one aspect we speak of it as I, each one of us, because this I is in time and space, it has a beginning and an ending, And under another aspect, we speak of it as self, I myself. But the two are a unity. It's not a lower story and an upper story or two halves or something. It's really one integral unity that is at the same time material and in time and space and immaterial and

[03:26]

Eternal. In time and eternal. In the now. We will have to say more about this now and eternity. I haven't spoken about that yet. But we live in this stubborn hell, and as long as we remember it, sort of in the background, like we remember our name, all goes well because this Self is what unites us all. It's the Christ Self within us. And as long as we keep this in mind, in the back of our minds, we will act out of that, and that makes a completely different interaction between people if we are aware that we are just playing different roles. But basically, we are one. This is Christ, playing to the Father, praying to the Father, playing to the Father, dancing before the Father like the eternal wisdom, the divine wisdom that plays and dances before the Father.

[04:34]

That image was also very important to call the demesis. And as long as we keep this in mind, everything goes well, both personally for us and in the community. But the moment we forget it, this I shrivels up and becomes the little ego, fearful, that's the first thing, and out of this fear, aggressive, and becomes a rival to all others, and becomes because it is fearful that there isn't enough around, and this is bad enough for the individual, but when a society is now run by egos, It is a violent society, a fearful society, and a rivalrous society, and a greedy society.

[05:43]

And that is unfortunately what characterizes our society today, and has characterized that power pyramid ever since our civilization began 5,000 years ago. In the book that we are reading in the Reflectory there are again and again very clear references to this power pyramid and to the chosen people of God's plan as being something completely different than this power structure. Once you learn to it, you hear it again and again in the book. So pay attention to that. It's really interesting. It's all there. And we saw then that the opposite of this power pyramid is a network, a network structure, which is exactly what Jesus had in mind for the kingdom of God, for this little community in

[06:51]

in the midst of whom God reigned. That was the kingdom of God, these little communities that he established. It wasn't just one. According to contemporary exegesis, he was wandering around with the disciples, and in different places, you had these little groups of disciples that were sedentary. And there, God's law ruled and not the Roman law. That ultimately brought him into trouble because he undermined, very successfully undermined, this power structure. And that Jesus was crucified shows that this was not a religious issue. There were religious issues at this time, but In the telling and particularly then in theological reflections, it has not always come out so clearly that the reason for his poor crucifixion was always subversion of the

[08:08]

order of the state. That was the only reason. And there were actually only two kinds of people crucified—slaves that were run away, because everything was built on slavery, and if a slave ran away, that was a rift in the social structure. It destroyed the social order. and revolutionary. And Jesus was a revolutionary. And when he foretold his death on the cross, which is historically true. Of course, we have it in the Bible, in the New Testament, in the Gospels, but it is also historically quite likely that he anticipated that he would be crucified because what was the just under this unjust structure was the so-called just punishment for exactly what he did.

[09:11]

He undermined this power structure. He said, among you it should be different. The greatest among you should be the servant of God. And that is characterized through not fear, but trust, faith. It's a faith community, faith in God, trust in life. It's a nonviolent community. It's a cooperative community instead of rivalry, and it's a sharing community instead of gain. And that characterizes both the little communities that Jesus established in his lifetime and the Jerusalem community after his death, after the apostles. and the monastic community that always hop back to the community in Jerusalem and thereby to the Kingdom of God as Jesus foresaw it.

[10:19]

And if we live that way, we will provide that important service which the monastic community at all times, every monastic community, is supposed to provide for the church, for the church structure, the institutional church, that is always in great danger to turn into a power pyramid. to provide another form of Christian living. And that is why we have all these people coming to monasteries who are very often, I'm pretty sure that must be here the same thing, but it certainly is in Austria in the monasteries, And everywhere I come across monasteries, people come who would have nothing to do with the official church. Our prior in Hudaikin says, at the Sunday Mass, we have probably

[11:26]

two-thirds of the people have left the church. They are unchurched. You know, they have to pay church taxes, and so it's very clear, are you in or out? If you don't pay the taxes, you're out. It's a very unfortunate situation. Hitler started it, you see, and he thought if people had to pay taxes for being in the church, then They would all leave the church, but nobody left. Everybody was very happy to pay these taxes just to spite him. But then when the war was over, the bishops found it so convenient that they continued this. It's a terrible situation now. And the mailman comes every week and brings a bag of letters and says, another 500 have left the church. So it's terrible, but this is the situation. They have not left Christ. They love Jesus, and they have not left Christian living or values, but they don't want to have anything to do with this power structure of the Orphanage Church.

[12:36]

And we provide for the unchurched. And in various ways, this is true of all the monks. And that is one of the most important aspects of our hospitality, you see. Hospitality is Among other things, hospitality to one another. In the community, we are hospitable to one another. We see one another with openness, with love. We look for what does the other one need, and that sort of thing. But the monastery and the community as a whole is open to our guests. And one of the most important things that we provide is the experience of a community that is not a power structure, but is a kingdom of God, as Jesus envisaged it.

[13:37]

or the Jerusalem community, or the early Franciscan community. Again and again in the church, monasteries were not the only ones, because they too turned then into power structures everywhere and had to be reformed over and over again. There were many many different ways in which this idea of the Kingdom of God was revised and it was always non-violent, fearless, non-violent, faith community, cooperating and sharing. God Today, the Catholic Worker, for instance, that's a good example in our own time, And the monastery is called to be that. And the way we receive people, of course one receives them with kindness, and kindness is exactly what you do when you are yourself.

[14:46]

I myself do know that everybody is of the same kind, because we live in Christ and Christ lives in us, and out of this same kind comes the kindness. That is how one behaves to those with whom one belongs together. That's morality. So all this springs out of the creation myth of the question, who am I? And I am At the same time, nothing, and alive with the Spirit of God. Alive with the Spirit of God. And the community itself, humble, thinking of itself as nothing, but alive with the Spirit of God, and sharing that, and welcoming everybody who comes. Now we come to the second great myth, which is the answer to the second great question.

[15:59]

The first question was, who am I? I asked you to anticipate what the second question was. Probably one could give a variety of answers that would not be wrong, but sort of the simplest way that I have found to say it is, what is life all about? If you have these two questions answered, everything flows. Who am I and what is life all about? People have asked that forever and ever. What really is is this life all about? And the answer to that question is the hero myth. The myth of the hero. And it exists in thousands, in ten thousands of forms, very, very different from one another.

[17:05]

But just as the creation myth or the myth of origin exists in many forms and has one basic pattern, so also the hero myth has one clear pattern that is repeated sometimes more successfully, sometimes less successfully, and we will see what successful means in this context for the storyteller. The great researcher in myth, the great anthropologist of our time, wrote a book called The Hero with a Thousand Faces. A hero with a thousand faces. There is one hero that is a human being living that has a thousand faces.

[18:10]

That was Joseph Campbell. He is very well known and has a television series about his work that is very well known. So maybe you are familiar with him. And Joseph Campbell wrote this important book, A Hero with a Thousand Faces. And in this book, he shows this pattern that repeats itself over and over again. And I will first give you the simplest form and then flesh it out a little bit. It has three phases. one can break it down in smaller units, but basically it has three phases. The first phase of this movement, the first phase of this movement is that the hero is thinking out, thinking out

[19:11]

And think it out for identification. Think it out means the hero must be somebody special, because what's the point in telling a story about a nobody? The storyteller tries to make the hero special. but not so special that it becomes a freak. You have to be able to identify with the hero because this is the story about you. So, special, thinking out, but for identification. And this first phase leads to the hero going out. going out, that means going out from the accustomed environment, going out from the community, you know, goes out. That is always there in one form or the other, sometimes obvious, sometimes not.

[20:18]

I can illustrate these three steps. fairy tales, because fairy tales are very frequently hero myths that have sort of been told and told and told and then come down to nursery proportions and are told to the children. But we find many hero myths among fairy tales, and Little Red Riding Hood would be a good example. Everybody knows it. It's a good example for the hero myth. The first phase, Little Red Riding Hood, is think it out. She needs a special little girl because she has this little hat that her grandmother has given her, a special hat. So little girls, to whom this story is told, can certainly identify with her, but she is still special and she has this little red riding hood, red cap. And she goes out, she's sent out to her mother to go into the forest and visit her grandmother.

[21:25]

It's very dangerous, the forest. This is a fairy tale that comes from the times. when in Europe the forests were really very dangerous areas where there were robbers and there were wolves and there were wild animals and so the mother cautions Little Red Riding Hood be very careful especially with wolves and when the wolves come just run don't talk with him and don't get involved with that wolf. And that's the first phase typically mirror singled out for identification and goes out, in this case, into the room. The middle part of the mirror myth is And the krieg is the argon, the battle or the disaster. The middle part is, the essence of the middle part is that the hero has now to deal with something

[22:33]

which he cannot get under control, but has to deal with. He can't evade it, but he can't control it either. He has to deal with it. And, of course, the two typical situations in human life where we have to deal with something that we cannot manage is love and death. And therefore, love or death, or love and death, are usually the forms in which the storyteller tells the middle part. And in the case of Little Red Riding Hood, well, she does meet the wolf. She is not obedient to the grandmother. The wolf says, look at all these nice flowers. You can bring the grandmother a bouquet of flowers. Why don't you bring her some flowers? And so she starts picking flowers. And meanwhile, the wolf sneaks into the house of the grandmother.

[23:36]

She has told him exactly where she lives and so forth. Sneaks in. And eats the grandmother, puts on the nightgown of the grandmother and the little hat of the grandmother and lies in bed. And then the little riding hood comes and is surprised the grandmother doesn't really look the way she normally looks. The grandmother, why do you have such a long nose? And the wolf says, I can smell you better. A grandmother, why do you have such big eyes? Oh, they can see you better." And she said, uncautiously, she said, a grandmother, why do you have such big teeth? And the woman said, that they can snap you better and eat you up. That is death in a childhood proportion, but this is exactly what you would expect at that point of the hill, in the middle of it.

[24:43]

There has to be death. And one can See, but I will say this later, I will go again about into these three phases a little more in detail, that the hero has to be dead, has to be dead, and not just dead, but as children say, dead, dead, dead, completely dead. That's what happens. And then comes the third phase. The third phase, again summarized, the hero is dead and yet lives, and comes back to the community, he's gone out from the community, now he comes back to the community as life bringer. So in the case of Little Red Riding Hood, the hunter comes, Saves the situation.

[25:44]

Slits open the belly of the wolves. The grandmother hops out and is happy. Little Riding Hood hops out and is ready. They call all the neighbors and now they eat the cake that was in the basket of Little Red Riding Hood. and they drink the wine. It is very important that one doesn't forget to tell the children that part of the story, because that is the good ending. The end, everyone is celebrating life together. And that is always the end of the hero story, that everybody is celebrating life together as a community. Now, a little more about these phases, because if you compare the different stories, and I said there were thousands of them, if you compare them, you see what the storyteller considered successful, what they were driving at.

[26:55]

Just as I said this morning, In the creation myth, they were trying to make that nothing as nothing as possible. That's a different kind of story. So here, in the first phase, they are trying to make the hero really special. And it's for us particularly, in our context here, and also in the context in which Frank Damascus used to speak about it, it is very important to see what the different storytellers use to make the hero so special. And it begins already with the conception of the hero, and very frequently the hero is conceived by a virgin, which is not unusual. In fact, that is a very frequent sort of feature of the hero story.

[28:05]

particularly also with Native American hero stories. A sun ray will hit the mother and then she conceives from the sun ray a child that is the son of the sun. Sun boy is one of those stories. Or the mother would go along and have a pepper in her mouth, because that's before chewing gum. We still did that as kids, actually, when we were hiking. You take a pepper in your mouth and you sort of move it around and it keeps your saliva running. And so this Indian version also goes around, and then accidentally she stumbles and swallows this stone. And this stone, she conceives this hero, and it's stone boy, and he becomes a rock of a man, and he only needs to throw himself on somebody.

[29:10]

His enemies are squash. So conception, special conception, is one of those ways in which—it's not always a virginal conception, but often from an animal, for instance, totem animals. Then special pregnancy. For instance, The child would already do special things while he's still in the womb of the mother. The best image is John the Baptist, you know, who recognizes his cousin, the Savior, in the childhood story according to Luke. In Montserrat, I never was in Montserrat, but I suppose some of you were in Montserrat.

[30:13]

In Montserrat there is a statue of the Visitation. In the Middle Ages that was very popular to have. statues of the visitation, especially on church doors, on one door a Virgin and on the other door Elizabeth. And then they had the babies carved on the bellies of the mothers. And sometimes they had a little glass window and you saw the babies sitting inside. And in Montserrat, there is a little Saint John the Baptist sitting inside of the belly of St. Elizabeth, and he shows his joy by playing a violin. So it's the epitome of a spiritual pregnancy. He shows his joy by making music and rejoicing. And then special fur.

[31:15]

Very frequently, the hero is born in a place where one isn't normally born. The mother can't give birth, can't give birth, has to go to some other place. Buddha, for instance, there are also lots of births of childhood door is here where the child is always among Buddha. His mother has to go under a special tree in the garden and give birth to him, and gives birth to him out of her side. He comes out of the side of the body. So, special birth. Then as soon as the child is born, he is already special. Hercules is born and he's still in diapers, and he's so strong that he tears a dragon into pieces. The strong child and the wise child. Of course, again, the 12-year-old Jesus in the temple fits there very well.

[32:18]

Those are ways in which the gospel The gospel tellers, the evangelists, showed Jesus is our hero. That was the way of saying that, and people at the time understood that perfectly well. That was sort of the way one told stories. Now, at the time of St. Thomas, We would explain the fact that the Christ story was cast into this hero mode by saying, with C.S. Lewis – C.S. Lewis put that into writing for the first time, as far as I know – that humankind dreamed about the coming, THE coming hero.

[33:20]

It was a dream, and in a thousand forms they dreamed, and then the dream became reality, or the myth became history. That was the way we spoke about it. Nowadays exegetes would rather approach it in a different way and would say, well, they started with the insight that Jesus was our hero and then gave the story, or added to the story, this childhood story that would sing him out as special for identification. Then the second phase, and I said already that in the second phase, the storyteller thinks he or she is successful when they make the hero as dead as possible. And it isn't enough that he's dead. God has to be, if he's very successful, torn to pieces, just torn to pieces, cut up.

[34:31]

annihilated, and yet he lives. We have that, of course, the lamb that was slain, and behold, he lives. And we have that, too, and that points to, again, to Jesus as our hero. And then the third, and yet he lives, leads already to the third phase, where the hero comes as life-bringer. And that can also take a great variety of forms, and I will tell you still one other myth, Little Red Riding Hood is really very sort of childish and almost childish form of telling about it. But one great myth that was also important to Father Damascus was the myth of Orpheus.

[35:34]

It's a rather complex myth, a very beautiful story, and also connected again with Rilke, because Rilke, one of his most important cycle of poems is the sonnets to Orpheus, and so the finger of Orpheus was very important. And Orpheus was often taken By the early Christians in Rome, the statues of Orpheus were taken and adapted to be Christ's statues. And the Good Shepherd that we have up there is inspired by this fact. But Orpheus often has a lyre, and this one has a sheep. The Good Shepherd also came in there, but Orpheus had the lyre, and Christ was the one who praises the Father. He sings the eternal praise before the Father.

[36:35]

And then Orpheus The first phase is that Orpheus is singled out already because he was half-divine, he was the son of a muse, that's why he was a great musician, and of a prince. So he was a prince and a great musician. And he's a greater musician than anybody, any other living musician. In fact, he moves not only the hearts of humans, but he moves animals, and the wild animals become tame when Walter is praised. And the trees uproot themselves and start dancing. He's a very successful musician. And he also is very blessed by marrying Juvenici, who is a beautiful woman, and they are very happy together.

[37:50]

and they are newly married, and she is still with her bridesmaids, dancing in the meadow, and steps on a viper that bites her, and she dies. And that is now the end of this first happy phase. And what we can, as human beings, identify also with this loss, you see, the joy and the loss. And then, Orpheus is so sad that he decides to follow his wife into the netherworld. There he goes out now from the world of the living into the netherworld. world of the dead, and he finds an entrance, and he goes down into the netherworld, and he says, I will sing before Pluto, and I will move the heart of Pluto, and I will sing before Persephone, because Pluto had raped and taken away Persephone and taken her down in the netherworld, so she had experienced what early death means.

[39:06]

I will move them, I will sing for them. So he sings down there, and he so moves everybody, all the dead souls down there, that they all weep. And Milton describes that very, very beautifully. my eyes. Love built the soul of authors to sing such notes as warbled to the string through iron tears from Pluto's eye cheeks.

[40:07]

and made hell grand. What love is huge. Aion, yes, the god of the netherworld, the god of death. We can't read humans, but Aion is a beautiful, beautiful image. And he granted the privilege that we could take a relic back up on loan, because she said, I only want her on loan. She died too soon. She should live out her life, then you can have her back. But on loan, and the only condition is, on the way up you must not look back. Only when you are in the sunlight, and until you are in daylight, back in the world of living, then you can look at her, but you must not look at her before that.

[41:10]

And so it's very difficult to go to praise the liar, hopes that she's following him, listens for the footsteps, he's not so sure, but he stays with his vow and does not turn back, and he gets into the sunlight. And in the sunlight, assuming he's in the sunlight, he turns around, but she is not in the sunlight yet. She is still in the shade. He didn't wait until she was in the sunlight. And so he just sees her waving and disappearing back down into the Netherworld. So it's one of the few stories where... He's not so successful, but with her he dies, of course. He dies with her, in a sense, and from then on he sings only very sad melodies, and everything reads that he is singing, and he stays faithful to her, and he refuses to marry or even look at any other woman.

[42:24]

And now, this is still all part of the central phase of the experiment, now the women that celebrate this These Rites of Bacchus, they are frenzied, they are drunk with wine and frenzied and wild, and they are so angered by him because he is faithful to the religion that they tear him to pieces, limb from limb. And that is not the climax of this central phase. And now comes the third phase. Yes, he is dead, but his head, which they have torn off, floats down the river, still singing. And his lyre is taken up by Zeus into the sky and becomes one of the constellations.

[43:31]

And Rilke says, this is a beautiful interpretation, He was not torn to pieces and left there. He was distributed as communion is distributed. And now he sings in the rocks and in the lions and everything. And he says, don't ask who sings. Wherever there is singing, it's obvious that sings. wherever they're singing, it's off with that thing. So that is a very different and much more complex here of myth, to give you an example of that. But Our question is now, how can we take out of this type of story the answer? How can we simplify the answer to the question, what is life all about?

[44:37]

And of course, One should wash out one's mouth every time one does that, because one should leave the story, that would be the right thing. But for our purposes, one can say that what it all amounts to is that life is all about dying into greater fullness of life. That's what it is, dying into greater fullness of life. And that is verified by human experience over and over. Who of us can't remember a situation in our life way back somewhere that was really like a death, maybe more difficult than physical death, real dying? Now, many years later, we look at it and it was the beginning of a new kind of life, and we would not have this life in its fullness if it hadn't been for this death.

[45:52]

And this happens not only once, maybe once or twice in a lifetime in a real big way, but many times in a little way. In everyday life you have to die to something and come... And if you have the courage to die, you come alive in a new way. And courage comes from the word core, heart. So if you have the heart, one says it, if you have the heart, you really go with it. But there are two different attitudes that we can have to this dying, or to this anxiety, and fright into which we come, when something like that threatens. We can either courageously go with it, trusting in life, life will get me there, or we can resist it.

[46:57]

And resistant is fear. So, we must distinguish between anxiety and fear, between being frightened and being fearful. We cannot help being frightened. If something frightening happens, we are frightened. If something frightening happens, we are anxious. That is not under our control. What we can go with is courage and trust and faith, or we can resist it. And what happens when you resist it? You get stuck in that narrow spot. And, of course, this is the way we came into this life. We have all come through a very narrow birth canal that was our first birth. And probably the feelings, the bodily feelings that we have when we get anxious go back to our earliest experiences as infants, as babies, when we were born. It's renewed every time we get into a narrow spot, as we call it, a narrow spot.

[48:04]

But then, at that time, instinctively, we still went simply through, and were born, and every time we now do it willingly, trusting in life, we also are born into a new life. And we can even project that to the greatest anxiety, that's the fear of death, or the fright of death, and we can feel death and then we are already stuck in it long before it comes. Or we can simply trust, faith will bring me through. I don't know what's on the other side, except whenever I have died, I have died into a greater life. So that I trust. The God of life, in whose hands I am, will also bring me on the other side of that narrow path, the narrowest of all, into fullness of life. And in that respect, this first one, this distinction between anxiety and fear is very important.

[49:12]

The emphasis on faith is very important, and trust and courage. Our hero is Jesus Christ, the one that has shown us what it means to be human. And the gospel story of Jesus being singled out for every human being to identify with, dying a gruesome death, and behold, he lives, resurrection, that is a history the story of our hero. And we will see tomorrow and the next day how this plays out in our life as a ritual, and eventually in life. That's those other steps, but that would be too much from Kathy that on one evening, for this evening only,

[50:15]

The question, what is life all about, is answered by a story, many, many different stories, also the gospel story, in a way that says life is all about dying into greater life, over and over. Let's take that into sleep, which is also a little bad. Sleep is a little bad. We have to let go. Many people suffer from sleeplessness because they fear. In a sense, a little frightening when it's dark and you close your eyes and you're gone. And so, for us, fortunately, You have courage and instinct and you do it. But some people get sleepless because they resist it. They just let it go. So, when we pray in our conference, it leads us through the night.

[51:24]

It serves us through the night. Then it's discouraged, we die a little bit, and come reborn the next day. Glory be to the Father, to the Son, and the Holy Spirit, as it was in the beginning, is now, and ever shall be, world without end. Amen.

[51:58]

@Transcribed_v004
@Text_v004
@Score_JJ