You are currently logged-out. You can log-in or create an account to see more talks, save favorites, and more.
Shuso Talk
#shuso-talk
The talk centers on the theme of "sharing the road," drawing from personal anecdotes and teachings from Reverend Ryo Imamura, a Jodo Shinshu minister. It discusses interdependence in everyday life, illustrated through driving analogies and experiences of support and kindness from others. Additional themes include the diversity and multiculturalism within religious practices, with a focus on the influence of Buddhist teachings such as the Jodo Shinshu practice of gratitude, and reflections on how diverse cultural backgrounds enrich community life. The speaker advocates for recognizing the dynamic intersection of personal boundaries and community engagement, supported by literary references.
Referenced Works and Individuals:
-
Reverend Ryo Imamura: A Jodo Shinshu minister discussed for his contributions on Buddhist psychology, and his personal history which highlights the challenges of racism from his upbringing in an internment camp. His perspectives on gratitude and interdependence are emphasized.
-
"The Practice of Gratitude" by Reverend Ryo Imamura: A talk that addresses the significance of gratitude in Pure Land Buddhism and challenges of materialistic perspectives in fostering true appreciation for interdependence.
-
A New Religious America by Diana Eck: This book explores the religious diversity in the United States and offers insights into the impact of global migration on American religious landscapes, stressing pluralism in a multicultural society.
-
Robert Frost's "Mending Wall": A poem invoked to reflect on the balance between necessary boundaries and communal life, illustrating how barriers can both separate and bring people together in shared efforts.
-
The Pluralism Project by Diana Eck: An initiative examining the evolving religious diversity in America, emphasizing the dynamic changes in global religious practices as they intersect with American life.
AI Suggested Title: Roads to Connected Gratitude
Side: A
Speaker: Jisan Tova Green
Location: ZMC
Possible Title: Shuso Talk
Additional text: Copy
@AI-Vision_v003
It was a great treat to walk across the bridge past all the jack-o'-lanterns this morning. And it's also amazing to see Iris on the altar on November 1st. So this morning is the first of the month and a friend once told me that if you jump out of bed backwards on the first day of the month, you'll have good luck for the whole month. So I did it and we'll see. So what I'd like to talk about today is sharing the road and that's kind of the title of my talk and I'd like to start with a couple of stories. The first one, this past summer, Leanne and I were driving to Green Gulch for a meeting of the diversity and multiculturalism committee of the board. The committee meets every month alternating between Green Gulch and City Center.
[01:06]
And that month it was at Green Gulch, so it was a long trip. And we talked and talked. And then Leanne suggested listening to a tape. She had brought with her a couple of tapes from a conference. that had been held a few months before at Spirit Rock. And it was the first Asian American and Pacific Islander Dharma retreat that ever had been held in the United States. So we listened to a talk by Reverend Ryo Imamura, Reverend Imamura, he's a Jodo Shinshu minister, and he is the 18th generation of ministers in his family. This is a very long lineage, starting in the 14th century in Japan. And he himself is a professor at Evergreen State College in Olympia, Washington. He teaches Buddhist psychology and counsels students there.
[02:10]
And I found the whole talk very interesting, and I'm going to come back to more of it. But one story really caught my attention. And he was talking about some of the basic ideas about Jodo, Shinshu, Buddhism, and saying that we live on a continuum of opposites. On the one hand, we kind of have a very self-centered life, thinking that I'm the most important person in the world, kind of it's like everything revolves around me. And thinking that way, he might think I'm the most important driver on Highway 101. And that kind of attitude leads to hunking, people cutting each other off, trying to get in the fast lane, being really aggravated when someone's going at 55 miles an hour in the fast lane and you want to go faster. And he said, on the other hand, if you live with a sense of interdependence,
[03:17]
The idea is because of other people's efforts, I can accomplish something. Whatever I accomplish isn't just because of my own striving or what I put into it, but it rests on the efforts of many other people as well as my own. And if I'm thinking that way, driving along 101, we're all going in the same direction and we all want to get where we're going safely. Then, he said, we start rooting for each other. We're one big team going up Highway 101. and I just found that an amazing way to think about driving and it comes to mind frequently now when I'm driving on the road and it just the idea that we're all going there together and the The trip can be a lot more enjoyable if we're not... If we have that cooperative kind of mind instead of the competitive one.
[04:28]
So soon after that trip, I was driving again. I was driving to the city for a meeting of the personnel committee. And I left Tassajara really early in the morning. The meeting was at 10 o'clock. And... I was driving on 101 in Salinas when the car in front of me swerved to the left. I didn't know why, and I slowed down. And then I saw this huge piece of metal in the lane right in front of me. And I slowed down, but I couldn't avoid it. So I hit it and pulled off the road. and got out of the car, put on my blinkers, my emergency lights, and I looked to see what had happened, and this piece of metal was impaled under the front of my car. And the car wouldn't move. So I stood there. It was still just dawn and wondering what to do.
[05:33]
And I could see on the other side of the road, kind of in the distance, there was a gas station. And I thought about crossing the two lanes of highway to get to it. And it didn't seem like a very safe thing to do. And I kept hoping somebody would come and help me out. I didn't have a cell phone. And within five or 10 minutes, a tow truck pulled up right behind me. And the driver got out and he handed me this flyer, which I've saved. It says, tow trucks to the rescue. And And it's the Monterey County Area Freeway Service patrol, and they go around looking for stranded drivers on 101 and other highways in Monterey County. He jacked up my car and got the metal out and we could see there was some fluid on the highway and I didn't know what it was.
[06:35]
So he suggested I try starting the car and it went forward and I could break it and he then said I could drive it to the nearest exit and there was a Firestone tire place nearby and they would check it out for me. and he would follow me there to make sure I got there safely. So I got in the car, and I got to the Firestone place, and they were just opening. It was 7 o'clock, and the proprietor looked at the car, and he said, well, your front tire's a little low, so he filled it with air, and it looked like the fluid was just from the windshield wiper fluid, so it wasn't anything serious, and there was some rubber dragging on the... on the highway, but that also was just a tire guard. So I got in the car and went back onto 101. And just as I got to San Jose, the car started rocking and making some horrible sound. And I had just been thinking about where I was going to stop for breakfast.
[07:40]
And I pulled off the road and And as I pulled off, I saw a car following me off the highway. It was right near an exit. So I stopped and got out and the tire, my front right tire was totally flat and shredded. And then a man got out of the car behind my car and said, I saw your tire getting flat and I thought you were going to have some trouble and I wonder if I can help you. And this man was dressed for work. He had a white shirt and a tie and nice trousers. And he got... He helped me get the jack out of my car, which I hadn't used in a long time, managed to put it together and got out my spare tire. And I asked if there was anything I could do to help him. He said, can you tell me a joke? I have a terrible memory for jokes.
[08:43]
The only joke I could remember was about the Buddhist who goes to the hot dog vendor and and says, make me one with everything. And he thought it was funny. He hadn't heard it before. So he helped me. He changed the tire. He did it. I just told him the joke. And And then when he was done, I asked if... He didn't want money. I offered money. And I had a loaf of Tassajara bread in the back seat of my car because I was going to stay with a friend after the meeting. And he wouldn't even accept the loaf of bread. He just... Just... offered his, it seemed to me like he was a Bodhisattva on the highway. And I asked him what he did for work, and he said he was a traveling salesman for a pharmaceutical company, and that he spent a lot of time on the road, so he was always very vigilant about what was going on on the highway.
[09:47]
and that he found his job pretty meaningless. And I said, well, you did something very meaningful today. And I really, I was very grateful. And I got to the meeting at Zen Center 10 minutes before it started, amazingly. So thinking about the image of sharing the road And from Reverend Imamura's talk, I was thinking about how that relates to our life here at Tassajara and how the opposite of that, the kind of road rage. There are times when I know I experience that kind of intense irritation. So I was thinking about a few examples of sharing the road. And one thing that we do that always impresses me and makes me feel so...
[10:58]
what is it, joyous maybe, is when the produce comes and it's time to unload it and everyone picks up a box and goes down to the kitchen or the upper shack or the lower shack and within five minutes the whole truck is unloaded. And in the summer, often... Excuse me, that was a fly. Okay. In the summer, the town trip often arrives on Tuesday or Friday nights just as we're having supper. We've sat down in the student eating area and we're... eating and then the bell rings the town trip is there and everyone goes out and unloads the town trip truck and you know if one person were to do that it would it would be very hard but when all of us just take a box or two it just happens so easily and I can also remember when I was Fukuten in the kitchen there were some evenings in the summer when the crew would
[12:11]
wash the pots, the dishes, take out the compost, the garbage. We'd be finished in no time at all. I never had to say anything to anybody about what to do because there were some times when the crew just knew. People would see what needed to be done and do it, and it would get done, and we'd bow out. And there was some wonderful feeling those nights. It wasn't always like that. And in contrast, in thinking of other times when, and maybe you've had these moments of irritation when, for example, there was a practice period when you could pass the gamassio either after the second pot or the third pot. And there were some people who really wanted to pass it after the second pot was served and some who really wanted to wait till after the third pot was served. And so I was one of those people who liked to wait until the third bowl was served.
[13:20]
But the person sitting next to me who received the gomasio and passed it to me liked to pass it after the second bowl. And I was feeling, well, will I take it even though I don't want it now or... You know, what do I do with the gamasio? And just feeling the irritation wanting to do it my way. And it's such a little thing, but it can seem so big in that moment. One of the things about living here at Tassajara is that I think we have a chance to look at these moments when irritation arises and see what is actually going on. And from this Jodo Shinshu perspective, which isn't so different from any other Buddhist perspective, I think. And at those moments, we're just focusing on ourselves rather than on our interconnectedness.
[14:27]
So I wanted to say a little bit more about Reverend Imamura and... Because in his talk, he spoke about his life. And I found him a very inspiring person. He was born in 1944. And he was born at an internment camp in Hilo, Arizona. During, well, right after Pearl Harbor, there were over 100,000 Japanese and Japanese Americans living in the U.S. who were interned at camps all over the country. And among the first to be interned were... the leaders in the Japanese-American community, including all the ministers. And so Reverend Imamura's father was a Jodo Shin minister in Berkeley, actually, in Berkeley.
[15:33]
And so he was interned and... So Ryo Imamura was born in the camp. And then when the war was over, his family returned to Berkeley. And there was still quite a lot of anti-Japanese sentiment in probably all of California, probably all of the country, but in Berkeley, where he grew up. And it made him very sensitive to racism. for his whole life. He said during that time most Japanese families interacted with other families within the Japanese community because it was safe there and the world outside was very hostile. He went to a public school in Berkeley and he said luckily he was small, his sister was bigger and protected him because kids would beat him up. And he noticed as a boy that many people came to talk with his father and they would come to the temple very upset.
[16:46]
And then he noticed that they would leave calmer and comforted, having been comforted. And so... later in his life he tried to find out how Buddhism was relevant and helpful to people who were suffering. And eventually he trained to be a Jodo Shin minister himself and then got his doctorate in psychology. And at Evergreen he does a lot of counseling with students as well as teaching classes on Buddhism and Psychology and East-West Psychology. I haven't met him, but I hope someday that I will. And his talk also made me realize how little I know about Jodo Shinshu Buddhism. And Keith mentioned in his Way-Seeking Mind talk that he had been very welcomed at a Jodo Shin temple.
[17:49]
forget where it was. And I wonder how many, whether anybody else here has been to a Jodo Shin temple. I never have. You have? And they're all over California. I know there's one in Berkeley. There's in San Francisco. And Los Angeles has a large, large temple. It's actually the largest Buddhist sect in Japan and in the United States. And the name has changed to the Buddhist Churches of America. There are currently 60 temples in the U.S., 38 in Hawaii, and 13 in Canada. So... And it's one of the first Buddhist groups that... Actually, it's the first Buddhist group, the first Japanese Buddhist group that started in the States.
[18:53]
There were Chinese Buddhists who came before. So I just wanted to talk a little bit more about... some of the ideas that Reverend Imamura spoke about in his talk. His talk was called The Practice of Gratitude. And he said that... Pure land Buddhism is called the easy path, but for materialistic Americans, gratitude isn't easy. And it's very hard sometimes in our families, our work, and in our daily life to realize gratitude. Because we start from the idea that... wondering what the universe can do for us. And we miss that sense of interdependence and the idea that because of other people's efforts, we're able to accomplish whatever we accomplish.
[20:09]
And the phrase is, I have lived instead of I live. And he said, just as we do our meal chant before eating, in Jodo Shin they say, Ite dakimasu. Thanks to the beings that nourished me so that I may benefit other people. And that everything, even life itself, is a gift that we didn't really deserve. But we have it and we can repay with our loving kindness what others have given to us. And this is... someone who went to visit a Jodo Shin temple on a Sunday and went to visit the Sunday school in the temple,
[21:11]
And the youngest group of children, they were six and seven year olds, were making paper chains out of big pieces of yellow construction paper and putting the links together. And then they chanted, I am a link in Amida Buddha's golden chain of love that stretches around the world. I must keep my link bright and strong. May every link in Amida Buddha's golden chain of love become bright and strong, and may we all attain perfect peace. I thought that was a wonderful thing for six- and seven-year-olds to be learning. And then the next time, the older children, the second- and third-graders, were making... Let's see. They were coloring a book... called My Altar, My Obutsudan, because in Jodoshin homes, there are family altars, and they were cutting out all the various things that,
[22:25]
would go on the altar, the Buddha statue, the incense, the vase of flowers, kinds of things we have on our altar. And then chanting a prayer, Amida Buddha, I offer rice to say thank you. I burn incense to say thank you. I offer beautiful flowers and say thank you. I light the candle and say, thank you. Namu Amida Butsu. Praise to Amida Buddha, as the teacher said, the Buddhist way to say thank you. So they were learning gratitude, the practice of gratitude at a very young age. So one reason why I wanted to talk a little about Jodo Shin Buddhism is that there are so many different Buddhist groups in the United States, in all of our cities and towns.
[23:35]
And I think it's very easy to just... be focusing on our own practice, our own path, our own Soto Zen practice in school and not be so aware of all the other paths that there are in Buddhism and in certainly all the other religions in the United States. And we're very fortunate, I think, in this time because in almost any community in the United States you can find groups who are practicing all the different... I want to call them branches of Buddhism. And partly this is the result of...
[24:37]
all the immigrant groups who have come to the United States since 1965 from the Asian countries, in addition to the Chinese and Japanese Buddhists who were here much earlier. And then All of us might call, there are different words describing us convert Buddhists who were not born Buddhists but have chosen the Buddhist path and have chosen many different Buddhist paths, Theravadan, Tibetan, Zen, many students who are students of Thich Nhat Hanh. And the richness of all the paths available to us is something quite new.
[25:42]
And I've been reading a book that I've found extremely inspiring. It's called A New Religious America, written by Diana Eck, who's a professor of religion at Harvard University. In 1997, I think it was, my partner Fran got a fellowship at Harvard. She was the Bunting Peace Fellow. There's an institute at Radcliffe for women scholars. and they at the bunting institute scholars come for a year and they're supported to study whatever they are passionate about and they had one seat for a peace activist each year and so fran was the bunting peace fellow and i went with her to cambridge for the year and i was able to audit a class that diana echo is teaching at harvard on world religions and uh
[26:46]
It was maybe one of the most wonderful learning experiences I've ever had. She was working then on a project which has blossomed. It's called the Pluralism Project. And she was studying world religions in the United States. When she first became a professor of comparative religion, she went to India and... I spent a long time in Varanasi and wrote a book called Benares, City of Light. Benares is a city which has... If you walk down the street, or Varanasi is the name most of us know the city by, you see... monks in orange robes and processions carrying corpses to the Ganges to be cremated. And you'll hear chanting from little temples hidden in nooks and crannies.
[27:50]
It's a city that's just alive with spirituality. Anyway, Diana Eck wrote that book and was teaching world religions from the perspective of world religions being everywhere in the world. And then gradually she realized that her student body was changing. And one time a student came to her class. It was a class on... Hindu religious practices. And he was a second generation Indian student who had gone to a Hindu summer camp in the Poconos. And Diana Eck was very surprised she didn't know such a thing existed, and she realized that many of the students who were now coming to Harvard had grown up in the United States but in families that were Hindu or Muslim or Buddhist, and that the face of the student body at Harvard was changing greatly.
[28:58]
And partly this was due to the change in immigration laws In 1965, for a long period of time, the United States had a very restricted policy on immigrants, particularly from Asian countries, probably other countries as well. And that as this new immigration policy emerged, opened up immigration to people from so many parts of the world. They were bringing with them their cultures and religions. And I just want to refer to a few things that she said. The religious landscape of America has changed radically in the past 30 years, but most of us have not yet begun to see the dimensions and scope of that change.
[30:01]
So gradual has it been, and yet so colossal. And she describes the architecture, how the religious architecture of the United States is changing. Not all of us have seen the Toledo Mosque or the Nashville Temple, but we will see places like them if we keep our eyes open, even in our own communities. They are the architectural signs of a new religious America. And I can recall a few years ago when I was in New York, side around 98th Street, I was walking east of Lexington Avenue, and there was a huge mosque I had never seen before. So you don't have to go far to find the mosques, the Hindu temples, the Sikh gurdwaras. And... Along with...
[31:09]
the increased proliferation of temples and mosques and so on, the rich diversity of religions that are now in the United States. The United States originally was a Christian country, and some people still think of the United States as a Christian country, even though There are so many other religious groups in the United States. But with this diversity, Diana feels it's important to not just recognize the diversity, but to really understand the different religions
[32:21]
that are here without losing the perspective of our own religion. And that's what she calls pluralism. And she raises many questions whether we are able to work together across the lines of religious difference to create a society in which we actually know one another remains to be seen. And... And she says, religions are not like stones passed from hand to hand through the ages. They are dynamic movements, more like rivers, flowing, raging, creative, splitting, converging. The history of religions is unfolding before our eyes. Perhaps nowhere in the world is it more interesting to study the process of dynamic religious change in this new century than in America. because all of the world's religions are represented in the United States today.
[33:33]
And her point of view is the United States is changing because of that. Not only are the religions changing, but the United States is changing also. And so the question is how do we learn about one another's different religions and how do we learn to ask the questions that will help us understand. We're all here at Tassajara to practice the same practice. You may wonder why this is relevant to us. And how does it relate to our lives as we practice here together?
[34:42]
And I think it's because we're not all the same. Even though we're all Zen students, there are many other ways in which we bring very different life experiences together. with us to Tassajara. And so I want to say a little bit about some of the diversity and multiculturalism work that we've been doing here, especially for Tangario students who haven't been here last summer and Last summer and the two summers before, we had a number of workshops on diversity and multiculturalism. Three summers ago, the Buddhist Peace Fellowship chapter initiated it, and then the last two summers, Charlie Pokorny, the director, invited trainers to come and work with us once a month.
[35:46]
Two years ago, it was Hilda Gutierrez-Baldokin, who's a priest at City Center. And this last summer, it was Rainbow Jane Markell, who's a diversity trainer, who's now... She's living in, is it Arizona? Anyway, she's working with Native Americans right now. One of the things that Rainbow worked with us on last summer, which I found very powerful, was an exercise where we talked about ways in which as children, we had felt different early in our lives, some way in which we had felt different. And what came up for me was As a child, I was very chubby, and my grandmother took care of me and my sister quite often.
[36:50]
And when she took us to the playground, I think because she was very fearful, she would tell us not to run, not to climb on the monkey bars because we might fall. And I got to be very... I didn't feel very confident about doing physical things. And because of that and being chubby, when it came to games at school, I was the last one to be chosen on the softball team. And I also was afraid of balls. So if someone threw a ball at me, I would run the other way instead of catching it or trying to catch it. Anyway, I really felt different. I didn't like sports. I didn't like softball. I didn't even like volleyball. When my father tried to teach me to ride a bike, I didn't want him to take the training wheels off it.
[37:55]
I felt safe with the training wheels, but two wheels, I didn't learn to ride a bicycle until I was in college. When we talked about in our small... We got into small groups and talked about some of the ways we had felt different. All of us had chosen things that were painful in some way. And... Where we had felt... Not accepted by others or, you know, it was... you know, sometimes you can think of difference as being very positive, but for some reason we all chose things that were painful. And yet when we talked about these things with each other, it was something very...
[38:59]
helpful in knowing that I wasn't the only one who had had an experience like that. And also it enabled us to be more compassionate towards one another. And as we went on in that training to talk a little bit about our experience at Tassajara with people who were different from ourselves, and Rainbow encouraged us to ask kinds of questions of each other that might create more intimacy. And after that training, someone who I had been here at Tassajara with for several years, maybe I've said this before, but anyway, this person who was a friend asked me to talk with him about what it was like for me to be a lesbian at Tassajara.
[40:04]
And it was something we had never talked about. So my feeling about the work that Rainbow did was that it really opened up some avenues of conversation and ways of getting to know each other that seemed to me to be very healing, like to recognize that we're not all the same and that some of the ways in which we're different can enrich each other's experience if we learn about them and hear about them. So I think that we actually are very fortunate to be practicing here with people who are different from ourselves in age, I mean, Linda Ruth pointed out the age range from about 24 to 82. This is quite wonderful.
[41:06]
And one of the things I've always appreciated about living at Tassajara is that it's possible to have friends who are different ages than me. They're much younger. I think I'm one of the oldest. But for me to have friends who are in their 20s is really a wonderful gift. And we also differ in sexual orientation, in class background, and to some extent in our racial and cultural backgrounds. And I wish there were more uh, diversity at, at Tassajara. I think that's one of the, that is the reason why I've, I've been working on the diversity and multiculturalism committee and, um, this is a committee of the board and one of the, uh, one of the ways in which, you know, uh, uh,
[42:15]
Zen Center, I'll just say just a couple of words about Zen Center's vision. A few years ago, we've started working on a vision for Zen Center for the next 10, 20 years and beyond. And many people were questioned about their sense of where Zen Center's strengths were and where Zen Center could grow further. And seven goals were established for all of Zen Center that we're working towards now. And one of them has to do with increasing diversity and multiculturalism at Zen Center. So I want to kind of bring this to a close and say that as we share the road of this practice, how can we get to know one another, understand and appreciate our differences?
[43:31]
And I'd like to end with a poem by Robert Frost. For those of you, especially from other countries, you may not know who Robert Frost is. He's a poet from New England, from the northeast part of our country. He's no longer alive. He's a 20th century poet, though. He lived in the country, and where he lived, the fields were very rocky. And so in the process of clearing the land, farmers would make stone fences. Instead of wooden fences, they'd build stone walls to keep the cows in or the horses in. And this is a poem called Mending Wall. It's a long poem, so I've excerpted parts of it, so it's not the whole, it's not the entire poem. Something there is that doesn't love a wall, that sends the frozen groundswell under it and spills the upper boulders in the sun and makes gaps even two can pass abreast.
[44:50]
These gaps, no one has seen them made or heard them made, but at spring mending time we find them there. I let my neighbor know beyond the hill, and on a day we meet to walk the line and set the wall between us once again. We keep the wall between us as we go, to each the boulders that have fallen to each. We wear our fingers rough with handling them. Oh, just another kind of outside game, one on a side. It comes to little more. There where it is, we do not need the wall. He is all pine and I'm apple orchard. My apple trees will never get across and eat the cones under his pines, I tell him. He only says, good fences make good neighbors. Spring is the mischief in me, and I want a notion in his head.
[45:55]
Why do they make good neighbors? Isn't it where there are cows? But here there are no cows. Before I built a wall, I'd asked to know what I was walling in or walling out, and to whom I was like to give offense. Something there is that doesn't love a wall, that wants it down. So I think I have time for some questions. So questions or comments, if anybody would like to raise anything. What your state of mind was like when you had those encounters on the road. Well, much to my surprise, I was calm. You know, initially when I wondered... You know, it's interesting.
[46:58]
Leslie was going to the same meeting that I was, but she took a Tassajara vehicle, and I took my car because I wanted to get new tires. LAUGHTER And I was standing there thinking, maybe Leslie will drive by and see me. And somehow I thought you would save me, but you didn't. But I felt calm. And then when I got back in the car and I was driving and thinking everything was okay, And then the car started shaking. That made me nervous, because I didn't know how serious it was. But then again, when I got out and there was the flat tire, No, I wasn't very, very worried.
[48:01]
And when the man got out of his car and came over to help me, I wasn't afraid. You know, I've read so many stories about terrible things that happen to people on highways, but I really can't explain it. Okay. Yes, Valerie? Oh, I can't say it. And I don't have it with me. I thought about it. It's interesting. I wrote a poem a couple of summers ago about the 14-mile dirt road that we all have to come down to get to Tassajara and how the monastery needs the road.
[49:03]
The road helps us because... By the time we actually get to Tassajara, we've already been on a journey. Sometimes you think the journey begins when you get to Tassajara, but it happens before. So I don't have it memorized. Thank you for asking. Would you like me to post it? OK, I can do that. Kathy? Because something does not like a wall. Something does not like a wall. When people feel the need for walls, how do you respond to that when they feel boundaries? How do you feel about boundaries?
[50:07]
I think we need boundaries. I think boundaries are really important. And I think there are times when, I mean, times when boundaries are useful and times when they get in the way. And it's kind of knowing when to want to use take refuge in a boundary and when to let it go is this something that you're working with how do you think about it I guess I have a great deal of sympathy for the neighbor who
[51:36]
said, good fences make good neighbors. I felt that. I like Robert Perl's poetry very much, but still I felt great sympathy with his neighbor who said good fences. Did everyone hear what Kathy said? Kathy said she felt a lot of sympathy for the neighbor who said, good fences make good neighbors. I think that both are true, and especially we live very closely together at Tassajara, and I think for each of us there's a sense of some space that, that we need. The way we're able to live in community, I think, is that we do respect one another's boundaries. But I also think that it's good to know what we're walling in and walling out and when we can let those boundaries down.
[52:55]
I think because we're all working with the precepts with right speech in particular and it makes it it seems to make it possible to have both intimacy and respect for one another's what you call boundaries or privacy or I think it's kind of a dynamic relationship between boundaries and communicating and getting close and working out what that dynamic is in each relationship that we have here. So I think both are true. Good fences make good neighbors, and something there is that doesn't love a wall that wants it down.
[54:04]
Carolyn? I think this conversation reminds me of the formalization of having a formal relationship and how much intimacy that can be. Can people hear what Carolyn had to say? Can I try to rephrase? Carolyn was saying that within a formal relationship, or a formal practice relationship? I think every relationship is a formal practice relationship. So every relationship is a formal practice relationship.
[55:06]
Constructing the agreement about the boundaries of the relationship can bring more intimacy. Is that how you would say it? Yeah. Yeah. And I would agree. Yeah, Meg? I was just going to say that I think the poem is much more about figuring out where the appropriateness of a wall is. Because he acknowledges that you need it to keep the cows out of each other's fields, but that you don't need it where the trees aren't going to wander into each other. I don't feel like it's just saying, we should take down all the walls. He does bend them. where the cows are, but he wants to propose to his neighbor that . So it seems very much to me to be addressing that. Could you hear Meg? She said the poem seems to address the balance, that there are places where the walls are needed, like to keep the cows in, and other places where the walls aren't needed, like where it's just apple trees and pine trees.
[56:22]
So, yeah. Is that Everett? Yeah. That's a great question. Everett said a dynamic of the poem is the disagreement between the two neighbors, one who said, yes, we need a fence, and the other said, no, let's take it down. And it reminds me of the book Difficult Conversations. You know, sometimes you get into a conversation with someone and you have really opposing perspectives. And... What do you do? Well, this approach recommends that you try to have a learning conversation about it.
[57:25]
So if Robert Frost and his neighbor could get together over a cup of tea and say, well, tell me more about why you think good fences make good neighbors. What is your experience about that? What lead? Well, then you can't have the conversation. But if they did, I mean, I think the idea is to try to approach it as a situation where you can learn more about each other's points of view. It's not like one is right and the other one's wrong. they have reasons for having these different perspectives. And if you and I disagree about something, we might want to try to understand where each of us was coming from rather than by saying, well, I know I'm right.
[58:27]
You're wrong. And that doesn't really get you very far. But I think that does make the poem more interesting, right? Walter? I think that each of us has a wall and no wall. We have a wall because we need our own space and our own privacy, yet we live together. We want to live together. Yeah, Walter's saying there's both a wall because we want a privacy and no wall because we want to reach out, that we're choosing to live in community. What we're doing right here is living in community where there is no wall and yet there is a wall.
[59:39]
Sometimes I think that really happens in the Zendo. You know, we have our privacy. We're sitting individually, but we're all sitting together as well and bowing to each other. And it's a very communal practice that gives us privacy and space at the same time. Keith? Was it Keith? thank you for that image so yeah yes um is it rick i'm sorry i'm nearsighted so i can't really yeah it was just
[61:09]
different cultures come together in a new country. And one model is some attempt at assimilation, which maybe people try. And it doesn't always seem to work out very well. And the other extreme would be an isolation that also doesn't seem to work very well. Finding a way to honor diversity and maintain diversity just like this, I think this discussion of boundaries . Thank you, yeah. Diana talks about three ways of dealing with difference in our society, and the United States has has used all three or all three one of them is kind of exclude excluding people another one is kind of the melting pot image where you kind of try to make everybody the same and then the third is pluralism where you recognize the differences and um
[62:33]
where the living in harmony comes because the differences are recognized, not trying to make everybody the same. So I think that's what you're saying. Yeah. Maybe one last question. Yeah, I can feel my emotions rising during this conversation about diversity. And I guess in the vision quest, there's eight other categories. I can't remember all the categories that are equally important issues. As someone who came here really to study Buddhism and is very interested in the academic discourses, I understand that diversity is an American, kind of a new world phenomenon we have to deal with.
[63:42]
But I will admit that sometimes I feel like it's getting shoved down my throat a little bit. I mean, I feel pretty diverse. I'm not, but I also feel kind of diverse, but I also just feel like there's so many important issues at Zen Center. I long for discussions on pedagogy, like how are we being taught? Just academically, how are we being taught? I don't know if it's a question or not, but how can you relate to this? Pru brought up her strong feeling that diversity is only one of a number of areas that the Zen Center is looking at. Can I just rephrase? You feel it's being shoved down your throat and that she'd like more diversity.
[64:43]
discussion about pedagogy or how we're being taught or some of the other areas. And those are all being addressed in the vision plan. There's a whole area about priest and lay training, the path of the priest and the lay practitioner. I mean, all of these are being addressed. I think I chose to talk about diversity because it's something I feel very passionate about and I'm working on. within the structure of Zen Center. But I feel equally passionate about all of the others. I hope there'll be many dialogues about all of these things and how we learn what we learn, how we're trained. I think that's a very rich area to study and talk about.
[65:47]
So I don't think it's either or. Well, it's diversity. It's what we have to deal with. There's no escape from it, obviously, because it's our problem. Well, you could say it's our problem or it's our opportunity. Yeah. But diversity, it is something that... I don't know if it's just American. I think nowadays the whole world is getting all mixed up. But it is something that we... that is offered to us in a way to deal with. I see one more hand. Yes, okay, Judith. And this will be the last question. One of the things that I discovered this summer as we studied together about white racism is that, to put it in your terms, sharing the road
[67:06]
for a white person or a European American has a very different meaning from sharing your personal color. And I don't quite know if I can articulate all that I feel or understand about that, but I guess I just want to encourage the white people in this room, European Americans, to look into that. Thank you. Judith said she understands that sharing the road is a different experience for white people or Euro-Americans than it is for people of color. And she would like to encourage those of us who are Euro-Americans to explore that. So thank you. So that seems like a good note to end on. Thank you. They are intention.
[68:14]
@Transcribed_UNK
@Text_v005
@Score_85.75